Breakdown of netu ga aru noni sigoto he ikou to site iru kanozyo wo mite, minna kawaisou da to itte ita.
Questions & Answers about netu ga aru noni sigoto he ikou to site iru kanozyo wo mite, minna kawaisou da to itte ita.
Why is 熱 marked with が in 熱がある instead of を?
熱がある is a fixed expression meaning to have a fever.
In Japanese, ある often means there is / exists, so 熱がある is literally something like a fever exists. Because of that, 熱 is marked with が, not を.
This is different from English have. Japanese often does not use a direct-object pattern where English does.
- お金がある = I have money
- 時間がある = I have time
- 熱がある = I have a fever
So this is best learned as a set phrase.
What does のに mean here?
Here, のに means even though or although.
So:
- 熱があるのに = even though she has a fever
It introduces a contrast between two facts:
- she has a fever
- she is trying to go to work
That contrast is why the people around her feel sorry for her.
A useful comparison:
- から = because
- けど / が = but / although
- のに = although, with a stronger sense of despite that
So のに often sounds like in spite of that situation.
Why is it 仕事へ行こうとしている and not just 仕事へ行く?
行こうとしている means is trying to go or is about to go.
It is built from:
- 行こう = volitional form of 行く; let's go / I will go
- 〜とする = to attempt to do
- 〜としている = is trying to do / is in the process of attempting
So:
- 仕事へ行く = go to work
- 仕事へ行こうとする = try to go to work
- 仕事へ行こうとしている = is trying to go to work
This matters because the sentence is describing her state as people are watching her. She has not simply gone to work; she is making the effort to go despite having a fever.
How does volitional form + とする work?
This is a very common grammar pattern.
Structure:
- dictionary verb → volitional form + とする
Examples:
- 食べる → 食べようとする = try to eat
- 帰る → 帰ろうとする = try to go home
- 行く → 行こうとする = try to go
It can mean:
In this sentence, the trying meaning is the important one.
So 仕事へ行こうとしている彼女 means:
- the woman who is trying to go to work
Why is している used instead of just する in 行こうとしている?
している shows an ongoing state or action in progress.
Compare:
- 行こうとする = tries to go / will try to go / attempt to go
- 行こうとしている = is trying to go
In this sentence, the speaker is describing what they saw: she was in the middle of making that effort. So 〜としている gives a more vivid, ongoing feeling.
It fits well with 彼女を見て:
- seeing the woman who is trying to go to work
Why is へ used in 仕事へ行こうとしている? Could it be に?
Yes, に would also be possible here.
Both can mark destination with 行く:
- 仕事へ行く
- 仕事に行く
The difference is small here.
Very roughly:
- に marks the destination more directly
- へ emphasizes direction toward
In many everyday sentences with 行く, both are natural. So 仕事へ行こうとしている and 仕事に行こうとしている are both fine.
What is 彼女を見て doing in the sentence?
彼女を見て means seeing her or when they saw her.
It connects the scene to the reaction that follows:
- 彼女を見て、みんなかわいそうだと言っていた。
- Seeing her, everyone was saying she was pitiful / they felt sorry for her.
Here, 見て is the て-form of 見る, which can connect actions or circumstances.
So the flow is:
- they saw her
- they reacted by saying かわいそうだ
Why is 彼女 followed by を?
Because 彼女 is the object of 見る.
Inside 彼女を見て:
- 彼女 = her
- を = marks the direct object
- 見て = seeing
So:
- 彼女を見て = seeing her
This を belongs only to 見る. It does not mark 彼女 as the object of the whole sentence.
Why is 彼女 placed before を見て instead of earlier or later?
In Japanese, relative clauses come before the noun they describe.
So:
- 仕事へ行こうとしている彼女
- literally: [trying to go to work] her
- natural English: the woman who is trying to go to work
Then that whole noun phrase becomes the object of 見る:
- 仕事へ行こうとしている彼女を見て
- seeing the woman who was trying to go to work
This is very normal in Japanese. The descriptive part comes first, and the main noun comes last.
Why is it かわいそうだと and not just かわいそうと?
Because かわいそう behaves like a na-adjective / adjectival noun, so when it appears before と言う, it usually takes だ.
So:
- かわいそうだ = she is pitiful / poor thing
- かわいそうだと言う = say that she is pitiful
This is similar to:
- 静かだと言う
- 便利だと言う
With i-adjectives, you do not add だ:
- 暑いと言う
- not 暑いだと言う
So かわいそうだと is the normal form here.
What exactly does かわいそう mean here?
Here, かわいそう means something like:
- pitiful
- poor thing
- I feel sorry for her
It does not mean cute, even though it may look similar to かわいい.
That is a very common learner confusion:
- かわいい = cute
- かわいそう = pitiable / poor thing / deserving sympathy
In this sentence, everyone is reacting sympathetically because she has a fever but is still trying to go to work.
Why is the sentence ending with 言っていた instead of 言った or 言っている?
言っていた is the past form of 言っている, and here it often means was saying.
Compare:
- 言った = said
- 言っている = is saying
- 言っていた = was saying / had been saying
So みんなかわいそうだと言っていた gives the feeling that, at that time, people were making that comment.
It often describes a scene in progress in the past, which fits well with 見て:
- they saw her
- everyone was saying poor thing
Does みんなかわいそうだと言っていた mean everyone said she is pitiful, or that everyone felt sorry for her?
Literally, it means everyone was saying かわいそうだ.
In natural English, that may be translated in a few ways depending on context:
- everyone said poor thing
- everyone said she was pitiful
- everyone felt sorry for her
So the Japanese is built as reported speech, but the natural English meaning may sound more like an emotional reaction than a formal statement.
Is 彼女 the person who has the fever and is trying to go to work?
Yes.
The phrase before 彼女 modifies it:
- 熱があるのに仕事へ行こうとしている彼女
- the woman who, even though she has a fever, is trying to go to work
So all of that information belongs to 彼女.
Then the rest of the sentence tells us what happened when people saw her:
- ...彼女を見て、みんなかわいそうだと言っていた。
Can this sentence be broken into smaller chunks to understand the structure?
Yes. A very useful breakdown is:
熱があるのに
- even though she has a fever
仕事へ行こうとしている
- is trying to go to work
彼女
- the woman / her
Together:
- 熱があるのに仕事へ行こうとしている彼女
- the woman who is trying to go to work even though she has a fever
Then:
を見て
- seeing her
みんな
- everyone
かわいそうだと
- that she is pitiful / poor thing
言っていた
- was saying
So the overall structure is:
- [the woman ...] を見て、[everyone] [poor thing] と言っていた。
This kind of chunking is often the easiest way to read long Japanese sentences.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from netu ga aru noni sigoto he ikou to site iru kanozyo wo mite, minna kawaisou da to itte ita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions