Breakdown of La scie que tu m’as prêtée coupe bien, mais je n’aime pas scier quand il pleut.
Questions & Answers about La scie que tu m’as prêtée coupe bien, mais je n’aime pas scier quand il pleut.
Why does the sentence start with La scie? Why not just scie?
What is que doing in La scie que tu m’as prêtée?
Why is it m’as? What does m’ mean?
Why is prêtée spelled with an extra -e?
Because the past participle agrees with the preceding direct object in this structure.
The direct object is que, and que refers back to la scie, which is feminine singular.
So the past participle becomes feminine singular too:
- La scie que tu m’as prêtée
This is a very common point of difficulty for English speakers, because English does not make this kind of agreement.
So why isn’t it just La scie que tu m’as prêté?
Because with avoir, the past participle agrees when the direct object comes before the verb.
Compare:
What does coupe bien mean literally?
Literally, coupe bien means cuts well.
So:
- La scie ... coupe bien = The saw ... cuts well
French often uses couper this way for tools:
- Ce couteau coupe bien. = This knife cuts well.
- Cette tondeuse coupe mal. = This mower cuts badly.
So coupe bien is a very natural way to say that the saw works effectively.
Why is it je n’aime pas scier and not something like je n’aime pas je scie?
After aimer, French normally uses the infinitive when talking about liking or not liking an activity.
So:
- j’aime lire = I like reading / I like to read
- j’aime cuisiner = I like cooking / I like to cook
- je n’aime pas scier = I don’t like sawing / I don’t like to saw
That is why French uses scier (the infinitive), not a conjugated form.
What is the difference between la scie and scier?
Why does French say quand il pleut? What does il refer to?
In il pleut, the il does not refer to a real person or thing. It is just a required subject pronoun.
French needs a subject in a normal sentence, so weather expressions often use il:
- il pleut = it is raining
- il neige = it is snowing
- il fait froid = it is cold
So quand il pleut simply means when it rains.
Why is it n’aime pas with n’? Can people say j’aime pas?
In standard written French, negation is usually:
- ne ... pas
So:
- je n’aime pas = I do not like
Because aime starts with a vowel sound, ne becomes n’:
- je n’aime pas
In everyday spoken French, many people drop ne, so you will often hear:
- j’aime pas
But in careful writing and standard grammar, je n’aime pas is the expected form.
Why is the word order tu m’as prêtée instead of something like tu as prêtée à moi?
French normally uses object pronouns before the verb, not after it.
So:
Using à moi here would sound wrong for this structure.
French prefers the pronoun me / m’ before the verb.
This is one of the big differences from English word order.
How do you pronounce scie and scier?
They are pronounced differently:
- scie → roughly see
- scier → roughly see-yay
More exactly:
- scie = /si/
- scier = /sje/
That difference matters in the sentence:
- La scie = the saw
- scier = to saw
So even though they look very similar, they are not pronounced the same.
Why is there an apostrophe in m’as and n’aime?
Why is tu used here instead of vous?
Tu is the informal singular you.
So this sentence sounds like one person speaking casually to a friend, family member, child, or someone they know well:
If the speaker were addressing someone formally or more than one person, French would use vous:
- La scie que vous m’avez prêtée...
So tu tells you something about the relationship: it is informal.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from La scie que tu m’as prêtée coupe bien, mais je n’aime pas scier quand il pleut to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions