Breakdown of Em outubro, a Ana compra outro uniforme porque o antigo já não lhe serve.
Questions & Answers about Em outubro, a Ana compra outro uniforme porque o antigo já não lhe serve.
Why is it Em outubro and not No outubro?
Why is there an article before Ana: a Ana?
What tense is compra?
Compra is the 3rd person singular present indicative of comprar.
So it means she buys.
In this sentence, the present tense can describe something habitual or a situation presented as a general fact, for example something that happens around that time.
Why does Portuguese use the present tense here instead of a past or future tense?
Portuguese often uses the present tense for:
- habitual actions
- repeated events
- general statements
- narrative style
So a Ana compra outro uniforme can suggest something like:
- this is what she does in October
- this is a typical situation
- this is being told as a current fact
English can do something similar with she buys.
Why is it outro uniforme and not um outro uniforme?
In Portuguese, outro usually works on its own:
outro uniforme = another uniform
The idea of another one is already built into outro, so um is usually unnecessary.
um outro uniforme is possible in some contexts, but it sounds more marked or emphatic. The normal choice here is outro uniforme.
Why does o antigo not repeat the noun uniforme?
What exactly does já não mean?
What does lhe mean here?
Why is lhe before the verb: não lhe serve?
Because não triggers proclisis, which means the object pronoun comes before the verb.
In European Portuguese, object pronouns often come after the verb in simple affirmative sentences, but certain words force them to come before it. Não is one of the most important triggers.
So:
- serve-lhe = possible in an affirmative structure
- não lhe serve = correct here because of não
That is why the sentence has já não lhe serve, not já não serve-lhe.
Why is it lhe and not a direct object pronoun like a?
Does antigo simply mean old?
Not always in exactly the same way as English old.
Antigo often means:
- former
- previous
- old in the sense of not new
In this sentence, o antigo is best understood as:
- the old one
- the previous one
It does not necessarily emphasize that the uniform is worn out; the main idea is that it is the one she had before.
Why is there a comma after Em outubro?
The comma separates the introductory time expression from the rest of the sentence:
This is very natural in writing, especially when a sentence begins with a time phrase such as:
It helps readability. In some short sentences, the comma may be omitted, but here it is perfectly normal.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from Em outubro, a Ana compra outro uniforme porque o antigo já não lhe serve to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.
- ✓ Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓ Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓ Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions