Questions & Answers about Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa.
Why does the sentence start with qualcuno instead of using a subject pronoun like lui or lei?
Qualcuno means someone or somebody. It is an indefinite pronoun, used when the speaker does not know who the person is or does not want to say.
So in this sentence, qualcuno is the subject: the action was done by an unknown person.
You would use lui or lei only if you were referring to a specific male or female person already known in the conversation.
Why is it ha rubato? What tense is that?
Ha rubato is the passato prossimo, one of the main past tenses in Italian.
It is formed with:
- the present tense of avere or essere
- plus the past participle
Here:
- ha = he/she/it has from avere
- rubato = past participle of rubare (to steal)
So ha rubato literally looks like has stolen, but in Italian it is also the normal way to say stole in many everyday situations.
Why does rubare use avere and not essere?
Most transitive verbs in Italian use avere in compound tenses, and rubare is transitive because it takes a direct object: here, la borsa.
So:
- ha rubato la borsa = correct
Verbs that usually take essere are often verbs of movement, change of state, or reflexive verbs, but rubare is not one of them.
What does la borsa mean exactly? Could it mean more than one thing?
Why is there an article in la borsa? In English we might say someone stole my bag or someone stole a bag.
Italian uses articles very often, and la borsa means the bag.
This sentence specifically says the bag, not a bag. That usually implies a specific bag already known from the context.
Compare:
- Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa. = Someone stole the bag.
- Qualcuno ha rubato una borsa. = Someone stole a bag.
- Qualcuno mi ha rubato la borsa. = Someone stole my bag / stole the bag from me.
Italian often uses the definite article where English would use a possessive.
Why is the word order Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa? Could I change it?
This is the most neutral and natural word order in Italian:
subject + verb + object
You can change the order in some contexts, but it usually adds emphasis or sounds less neutral.
For example:
- La borsa, qualcuno l’ha rubata. = The bag, someone stole it.
This gives special emphasis to the bag.
For a basic statement, Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa is the standard order.
Why is it rubato and not something that changes to match la borsa, like an adjective would?
Good question. In ha rubato, the word rubato is a past participle used with avere. Normally, when a verb uses avere, the past participle does not agree with the direct object.
So:
- ha rubato la borsa
- ha rubato i soldi
- ha rubato le chiavi
The participle stays rubato.
Agreement can happen in some special cases, especially with direct object pronouns placed before the verb:
- L’ha rubata. = He/She stole it.
Here rubata agrees with la.
But in your original sentence, rubato is correct and normal.
Can qualcuno be used only for people?
Is qualcuno singular or plural? Why is the verb ha singular?
Could I also say qualcuno ha derubato?
Not in the same way.
There is a difference between:
So:
- Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa. = Someone stole the bag.
- Qualcuno ha derubato la signora. = Someone robbed the lady.
You can also say:
- Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa alla signora. = Someone stole the lady’s bag.
- Qualcuno ha derubato la signora della borsa. = Someone robbed the lady of her bag.
This is grammatically possible, but less basic and less common for beginners.
Could this sentence mean Someone has stolen the bag as well as Someone stole the bag?
Yes. The Italian passato prossimo often covers both ideas.
Depending on context, ha rubato can correspond to:
- stole
- has stolen
In everyday spoken Italian, passato prossimo is extremely common for completed past actions, especially in much of Italy.
So the exact English tense depends on the context, not just the Italian form by itself.
How would I make this sentence negative?
How would I turn this into a question?
In Italian, you can often make a question just by using intonation:
This can mean:
- Did someone steal the bag?
- Has someone stolen the bag?
You do not need an extra helping verb like English did.
If you want a more explicit question such as Who stole the bag?, you would say:
- Chi ha rubato la borsa?
If I wanted to say Someone stole her bag or his bag, would I still use la borsa?
Sometimes yes, sometimes no.
Italian often prefers the definite article where English uses a possessive, especially when the owner is clear from context:
- Le hanno rubato la borsa. = They stole her bag / his bag / the bag from her/him.
But if you want to state the ownership explicitly, you can use a possessive:
Be careful: sua can mean his, her, or even your (formal), depending on context. That is why Italian often prefers other structures when it wants to avoid ambiguity.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ItalianMaster Italian — from Qualcuno ha rubato la borsa to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions