Breakdown of La questione riguarda una posizione che dobbiamo considerare.
Questions & Answers about La questione riguarda una posizione che dobbiamo considerare.
Why is it la questione and not just questione?
In Italian, nouns usually need an article more often than in English. Here, la questione means the issue / the matter and it is the subject of the sentence.
So:
- la questione = the issue
- questione by itself would usually sound incomplete in a normal sentence like this
Italian often uses articles where English might be a little more flexible.
What does riguarda mean here?
Riguarda is from the verb riguardare.
In this sentence, it means:
- concerns
- involves
- has to do with
- sometimes regards
So La questione riguarda... means The issue concerns... or The matter involves...
Grammar-wise:
- riguarda = he/she/it concerns
- the subject is la questione, which is singular, so the verb is singular too
Why is riguarda singular and not plural?
What does una posizione mean in this sentence?
Literally, una posizione means a position. But in Italian, just like in English, posizione can have different meanings depending on context.
Possible meanings include:
- a physical position
- a role or post
- a standpoint
- an opinion or stance
In this sentence, it most likely means something like:
- a position
- a stance
- a standpoint
So it is probably not about physical location, but about an idea, role, or point of view that must be considered.
Why is it una posizione and not la posizione?
Una is the indefinite article, meaning a / an. It introduces something non-specific:
- una posizione = a position
If you said la posizione, it would mean the position, referring to a specific position already known from context.
So the sentence presents it as one position among possible others, not as an already identified one.
What is the job of che here?
Why is che used instead of cui?
Because here the relative pronoun is the direct object of considerare.
In other words:
When no preposition is needed, Italian normally uses che.
You usually use cui after a preposition, for example:
- la posizione di cui parliamo = the position we are talking about
- la persona a cui scrivo = the person I am writing to
So in your sentence, che is the correct choice.
Why is there no separate word for it in che dobbiamo considerare?
Because che already carries that function.
In English, we say:
- a position that we must consider
We do not say:
- a position that we must consider it
Italian works the same way here:
- una posizione che dobbiamo considerare
- not una posizione che la dobbiamo considerare in standard usage here
So che stands for the position inside the relative clause.
Why is it dobbiamo considerare and not something like consideriamo?
Dobbiamo considerare means we must consider or we have to consider.
- dobbiamo = we must / we have to
- considerare = to consider
This structure is very common in Italian:
- dovere + infinitive
Examples:
- devo studiare = I must study
- dobbiamo partire = we have to leave
If you said consideriamo, that would simply mean we consider or let's consider, depending on context. That is a different meaning.
So dobbiamo considerare adds the idea of necessity or obligation.
Why is considerare in the infinitive?
Because it follows dobbiamo, which is a conjugated form of dovere.
After modal verbs like these, Italian uses the infinitive:
So:
- dobbiamo considerare = we must consider
This is exactly parallel to English must consider.
Is dobbiamo closer to must or have to?
Is the sentence formal?
Yes, it sounds fairly neutral-to-formal, especially because of words like:
- questione
- riguarda
- posizione
- considerare
This is the kind of sentence you might see in:
- business writing
- academic discussion
- legal or administrative language
- formal spoken discussion
It is not unnatural in everyday Italian, but it is a bit more formal than very casual speech.
Could the sentence be rearranged in a different word order?
Yes, but the given order is the most natural and standard.
Current structure:
- La questione = subject
- riguarda = verb
- una posizione che dobbiamo considerare = object + relative clause
Italian does allow some flexibility, but changing the order may sound marked or stylistically different. For a learner, the original order is the safest and most neutral one.
Can riguardare ever mean something else?
Yes. Depending on context, riguardare can mean:
- to concern
- to pertain to
- to affect
- sometimes to look at again in more literal contexts, though that is less common in sentences like this
In your sentence, the meaning is clearly to concern / to involve.
So here:
- La questione riguarda... = The issue concerns...
What is the overall grammatical structure of the sentence?
It breaks down like this:
- La questione = subject
- riguarda = main verb
- una posizione = direct object of riguarda
- che dobbiamo considerare = relative clause describing posizione
So the pattern is:
[Subject] + [verb] + [noun] + [relative clause]
More literally:
- The issue concerns a position
- that we must consider
That is why the sentence feels long but is actually built in a very regular way.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ItalianMaster Italian — from La questione riguarda una posizione che dobbiamo considerare to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions