Breakdown of Marta dice che il gallo è rumoroso, ma che la gallina con i pulcini è molto carina.
Questions & Answers about Marta dice che il gallo è rumoroso, ma che la gallina con i pulcini è molto carina.
Why is che used twice: Marta dice che... , ma che...?
The first che introduces what Marta says: dice che... = says that...
The second che is repeated after ma to introduce a second, parallel clause:
In English, we often drop the second that, but Italian commonly keeps che here for clarity and balance. It sounds very natural.
You may also hear the second che omitted in some contexts, but in this sentence repeating it is elegant and standard.
What kind of che is this? Is it a relative pronoun like who/which, or does it mean that?
Here, both instances of che mean that and introduce a subordinate clause.
So:
- dice che... = says that...
- ma che... = but that...
This is not a relative che. It is not replacing who, which, or that as in the book that I read.
Why is there no article before Marta?
In standard Italian, proper names usually appear without an article.
So you say:
- Marta dice...
- Paolo pensa...
- Giulia vede...
In some regional varieties of Italian, especially in parts of northern Italy, people may use an article before first names in everyday speech, but that is not the standard form being used here.
Why do we have il gallo, la gallina, and i pulcini?
These are definite articles, equivalent to English the.
- il gallo = the rooster
- la gallina = the hen
- i pulcini = the chicks
They agree with the noun’s gender and number:
- il = masculine singular
- la = feminine singular
- i = masculine plural
Italian uses articles more regularly than English, so where English might sometimes leave them out, Italian often keeps them.
How do gallo, gallina, and pulcini work in terms of gender and number?
They are three different noun forms:
- gallo = masculine singular
- gallina = feminine singular
- pulcini = masculine plural
A native English speaker may notice that gallo and gallina are different words, not just one word with different endings. Italian often has separate masculine and feminine animal names.
Also, pulcini is plural. The singular is pulcino.
Why is the verb è singular in la gallina con i pulcini è molto carina? Aren’t there multiple animals there?
What exactly does con i pulcini modify?
Why do the adjectives change: rumoroso but carina?
Italian adjectives usually agree with the noun they describe in gender and number.
- gallo is masculine singular, so: rumoroso
- gallina is feminine singular, so: carina
Compare:
This agreement is one of the most important patterns in Italian grammar.
What does molto mean here, and why doesn’t it change form?
Here molto means very:
- molto carina = very cute
When molto modifies an adjective or adverb, it usually stays unchanged:
- molto carino
- molto carina
- molto belli
- molto rumorosa
It does not agree with the noun in this use.
But molto can also function as an adjective or pronoun, and then it can change form:
- molti pulcini = many chicks
- molta acqua = a lot of water
So in this sentence, molto is an adverb, which is why it stays the same.
Why is there an accent in è?
Can the second che be omitted?
Is the word order normal in this sentence?
Yes. This is a very standard Italian word order:
- Marta dice = subject + verb
- che il gallo è rumoroso = subordinate clause
- ma che la gallina con i pulcini è molto carina = second subordinate clause
Italian word order is often similar to English in simple statements, though Italian can be more flexible. This sentence is straightforward and neutral.
Could rumoroso and carina be used for people too, or only for animals?
Yes, both can be used for people too, but with context-dependent meanings.
- rumoroso = noisy, loud
- carino/carina = cute, nice, pleasant, sweet
So:
- un bambino rumoroso = a noisy child
- una ragazza carina = a cute / pretty girl
- un gesto carino = a nice gesture
In this sentence they describe animals, but the grammar is the same as when describing people or things.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning ItalianMaster Italian — from Marta dice che il gallo è rumoroso, ma che la gallina con i pulcini è molto carina to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions