Breakdown of Onaj golub opet sjedi na ogradi, a tata kaže da ga ne hranimo svaki dan.
Questions & Answers about Onaj golub opet sjedi na ogradi, a tata kaže da ga ne hranimo svaki dan.
Why is it onaj golub and not just golub? Does Croatian have words for the and a?
Croatian does not have articles like English the and a/an.
So:
- golub = pigeon / a pigeon / the pigeon
- onaj golub = that pigeon
Here onaj is a demonstrative, meaning that one over there. It points to a specific pigeon that the speakers both know or can see.
A rough comparison:
- ovaj golub = this pigeon
- taj golub = that pigeon / that pigeon near you or already mentioned
- onaj golub = that pigeon over there
So onaj adds a sense of distance or clear identification.
Why does golub stay as golub? What case is it in?
Golub is in the nominative singular, because it is the subject of the verb sjedi.
In this sentence:
- Onaj golub = the subject
- sjedi = the verb
So the basic structure is:
- Onaj golub sjedi = That pigeon is sitting
The noun stays in its dictionary form because subjects normally appear in the nominative.
What exactly does opet mean here?
Opet usually means again.
So:
- Onaj golub opet sjedi na ogradi = That pigeon is sitting on the fence again
Depending on context, opet can sometimes feel like:
- again
- once more
- there it is, doing the same thing again
It often carries a mild sense of repetition that the speaker notices or comments on.
Why is it sjedi? What form is that?
Sjedi is the 3rd person singular present tense of sjediti = to sit.
So:
- ja sjedim = I sit / am sitting
- ti sjediš = you sit / are sitting
- on/ona/ono sjedi = he/she/it sits / is sitting
Because golub is singular, the verb is singular too:
- Onaj golub sjedi = That pigeon is sitting
Croatian present tense can often translate both simple present and present continuous in English, depending on context.
Why is it na ogradi and not na ogradu?
This is a very common Croatian case question.
After na, the case depends on meaning:
- na + accusative = movement onto something
- na + locative = being on something
Here the pigeon is already sitting there, so this is location, not movement.
That is why we get:
- na ogradi = on the fence
Compare:
- Golub sjeda na ogradu. = The pigeon is sitting down onto the fence.
- Golub sjedi na ogradi. = The pigeon is sitting on the fence.
So ogradi is locative singular of ograda.
What is the difference between a and i here?
In this sentence, a means something like and, but with a slight contrast or shift of focus.
- a often means and / while / whereas / and then
- i is more straightforwardly and
So:
- Onaj golub opet sjedi na ogradi, a tata kaže... = That pigeon is sitting on the fence again, and Dad says...
But a feels a bit more like:
- ..., and meanwhile Dad says...
- ..., but Dad says... if there is a slight contrast
It links two ideas, but not as tightly as i would.
Why is it tata instead of otac?
Both can mean father, but they are used differently.
- tata = dad, informal and everyday
- otac = father, more formal or neutral
In normal family speech, tata is extremely common. It sounds natural and conversational.
So:
- tata kaže = Dad says
- otac kaže = Father says (more formal, less casual in everyday speech)
Also, even though tata ends in -a, it refers to a masculine person.
How does tata work grammatically if it ends in -a?
This is a good thing to notice, because it can look feminine at first.
Tata is a masculine noun referring to a male person, but it declines like many nouns ending in -a.
In the nominative singular, it is:
- tata
And with the verb, it behaves as masculine singular:
- tata kaže = Dad says
Some other forms are:
- tate = of Dad / Dad’s
- tati = to Dad
- tatu = Dad (object)
- s tatom = with Dad
So its ending looks similar to many feminine nouns, but its meaning and agreement are masculine.
What is da doing in tata kaže da...?
Here da introduces a subordinate clause, similar to English that.
So:
This is a very common pattern:
- kažem da... = I say that...
- mislim da... = I think that...
- znam da... = I know that...
So da is the word that connects the main clause and the reported statement.
Why is it ga? What does it refer to?
Ga is the unstressed short form of njega = him.
Here it refers back to golub.
So:
- ga ne hranimo = we do not feed him
Because golub is masculine animate, the object pronoun is:
- ga = him
Compare:
- Vidim ga. = I see him/it.
- Hranimo ga. = We feed him.
In everyday Croatian, short object pronouns like ga are extremely common.
Why is it da ga ne hranimo, not da ne ga hranimo?
This is about clitic word order.
Ga is a clitic: a short unstressed word that has to go in a special position in the clause. In Croatian, clitics usually come very early, in a fixed order.
So the natural order is:
not:
- da ne ga hranimo
You can think of ga as wanting to stay close to the beginning of the clause after da.
This kind of ordering is something learners usually need to get used to, because it does not match English word order.
Does ne hranimo mean we don’t feed or we shouldn’t feed?
Grammatically, ne hranimo is simply we do not feed.
- hranimo = we feed
- ne hranimo = we do not feed
But in a sentence like:
the natural meaning can depend on context. It may mean:
- Dad says that we don’t feed him every day or
- Dad says not to feed him every day or
- Dad says we shouldn’t feed him every day
So the literal grammar is plain present tense, but the whole sentence can sound like reported advice or a rule.
Why is it hranimo? Who is included in we?
Hranimo is the 1st person plural present tense of hraniti = to feed.
So:
- ja hranim = I feed
- ti hraniš = you feed
- mi hranimo = we feed
In this sentence, we means the speaker plus at least one other person. The exact group depends on context, for example:
- the speaker and siblings
- the family
- the people in the house
Croatian often leaves subject pronouns unstated, because the verb ending already shows the person and number.
So there is no need to say mi hranimo unless you want extra emphasis.
Why is it svaki dan and not some other case form?
Svaki dan is a common time expression meaning every day.
- svaki = every
- dan = day
Croatian often uses the accusative for expressions of time duration or repeated time references like this.
So:
- svaki dan = every day
- cijeli dan = all day
- jedan dan = one day
Even though there is no movement here, accusative is very common in time expressions.
Could the sentence word order be different?
Yes, Croatian word order is fairly flexible, but not completely free.
This sentence is very natural as:
Some parts could move for emphasis, for example:
- Opet onaj golub sjedi na ogradi...
- Tata kaže da ga svaki dan ne hranimo...
though this version changes the emphasis and can sound less neutral
However, clitics like ga have stricter placement rules than full words, so not everything can move around freely.
So the sentence you have is a normal, neutral everyday order.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from Onaj golub opet sjedi na ogradi, a tata kaže da ga ne hranimo svaki dan to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions