Breakdown of As iemand vra oor die beker op die tafel, sal ek sê dat dit nie myne is nie.
Questions & Answers about As iemand vra oor die beker op die tafel, sal ek sê dat dit nie myne is nie.
What does as mean here: if or when?
Does iemand mean someone or anyone?
It can cover both ideas.
In a sentence like this, iemand is an indefinite word meaning someone / anyone. Afrikaans does not make the same strict someone vs anyone distinction that English often does in conditional sentences. So in context, it means something like if someone asks or if anyone asks.
Why is it vra oor?
Why is there a comma after tafel?
Why is it sal ek sê and not ek sal sê?
Because Afrikaans uses verb-second word order in the main clause.
The whole opening clause As iemand vra oor die beker op die tafel takes the first position in the sentence. Once that first position is filled, the finite verb of the main clause comes next:
- As iemand vra oor die beker op die tafel, sal ek sê ...
So the order is:
- opening clause
- finite verb = sal
- subject = ek
If the sentence started directly with the subject, then you would get Ek sal sê ...
What does sal mean here?
Sal usually corresponds to will.
Here it shows what the speaker will say in that situation:
- sal ek sê = I will say
In conditional sentences like this, it can also feel a bit like I would say in English, depending on tone and context, but the basic idea is future or expected response.
Why is dat used after sê?
Dat means that and introduces the next clause:
It is very common after verbs like sê.
Afrikaans can sometimes omit dat, especially in speech, but if you do that, the word order often changes. Compare:
- ... sê dat dit nie myne is nie
- ... sê dit is nie myne nie
So dat is not just a vocabulary item; it also affects the structure of the clause that follows.
Why is it dat dit nie myne is nie and not dat dit is nie myne nie?
Why are there two nie words?
Because standard Afrikaans usually uses a double negative pattern.
The basic structure is:
- nie ... nie
So:
The first nie marks the negation, and the second nie closes it off at the end of the clause. This is one of the most famous features of Afrikaans grammar.
Why is the first nie before myne here?
Because the clause is subordinate and the verb is comes later.
Compare these two patterns:
In the main clause, is comes early, so nie follows it. In the dat-clause, the verb is pushed toward the end, so the negative structure shifts with it. The sentence is still the same idea, just with subordinate-clause word order.
Why is it myne and not my?
Because my means my, but myne means mine.
Compare:
So in your sentence, the noun beker is not repeated. Instead, Afrikaans uses the possessive pronoun myne, which stands on its own.
What does dit refer to?
Can dat be left out in a more natural spoken sentence?
Yes, very often.
A very natural spoken version would be:
As iemand vra oor die beker op die tafel, sal ek sê dit is nie myne nie.
Notice what happens:
- with dat: dat dit nie myne is nie
- without dat: dit is nie myne nie
So yes, dat can be omitted, but the word order usually switches back to the more direct main-clause pattern.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from As iemand vra oor die beker op die tafel, sal ek sê dat dit nie myne is nie to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions