Breakdown of Eu tinha dado a nova versão ao criador. Tinha-lhe mostrado o protótipo.
eu
I
novo
new / young
ter
to have
a
to / at (direction)
lhe
to him / to her / to you (formal)
dar
to give
mostrar
to show
o criador
the creator
a versão
the version
o protótipo
the prototype
Questions & Answers about Eu tinha dado a nova versão ao criador. Tinha-lhe mostrado o protótipo.
Why is the pronoun -lhe attached to Tinha instead of mostrado?
In compound tenses like the pluperfect (an auxiliary verb plus a past participle), object pronouns must attach to the auxiliary verb, never to the past participle. Therefore, it has to be Tinha-lhe mostrado and not Tinha mostrado-lhe.
Could I place the pronoun before the verb instead, like Lhe tinha mostrado?
In European Portuguese, sentences normally cannot start with an object pronoun. Because the second sentence starts directly with the verb, the pronoun must attach to the end of the auxiliary verb with a hyphen. Even if you had kept the subject pronoun, it would still be Eu tinha-lhe mostrado because affirmative subject pronouns are not 'magnet' words that pull the pronoun forward.
Who exactly does -lhe refer to in this context?
It refers back to ao criador (to the creator) from the first sentence. The verb mostrar (to show) takes an indirect object for the person being shown something, so we use the indirect object pronoun -lhe (to him).
I sometimes see a one-word past perfect tense (like dera or mostrara). Could I use that here instead of tinha dado and tinha mostrado?
Learn Eu tinha dado a nova versão ao criador. Tinha-lhe mostrado o protótipo and more in Portuguese
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free