Word
Você pensou que ele fosse antipático, mas ele é bastante acolhedor.
Meaning
You thought he was unfriendly, but he is quite welcoming.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Breakdown of Você pensou que ele fosse antipático, mas ele é bastante acolhedor.
ser
to be
ele
he / it (referring to a masculine noun)
você
you
mas
but
Questions & Answers about Você pensou que ele fosse antipático, mas ele é bastante acolhedor.
Why does pensou que take the subjunctive fosse here when the sentence is affirmative?
Normally, affirmative verbs of opinion like pensar, achar, and imaginar are followed by the indicative. However, when these verbs are in the past (pensou, achei, imaginava), Brazilian Portuguese often uses the imperfect subjunctive (fosse) to signal a counterfactual assumption — something you thought was true, but wasn't. Using fosse tells the listener right away that your impression of him was mistaken, even before the mas clause confirms it.
Could I say Você pensou que ele era antipático instead?
Yes, both fosse and era are very natural and common here. Using the imperfect indicative (era) simply reports what you believed at the time, leaving the twist for the second half of the sentence. Using the imperfect subjunctive (fosse) highlights from the very beginning that the assumption turned out to be false.
Why is pensou in the simple past instead of the imperfect pensava?
With verbs like pensar, achar, and jurar, Brazilians very frequently use the simple past (pensou, achei) to talk about a first impression or an assumption that has just been corrected. It frames that mistaken thought as a completed moment that ended once you saw the truth. You can also say Você pensava que ele fosse... if you want to emphasize that you held that belief over a longer period of time.