Eles selecionaram a Júlia por ter escrito uma ótima redação.

Questions & Answers about Eles selecionaram a Júlia por ter escrito uma ótima redação.

Why does the sentence use por ter escrito instead of por escrever?
After a preposition like por (for / because of), Portuguese uses an infinitive where English uses an -ing form. Using the compound infinitive ter escrito (having written) instead of the simple infinitive escrever (writing) makes the timeline clear: Júlia wrote the essay before they selected her. While por escrever can also be heard when the context makes the order of events obvious, por ter escrito is the most natural way to point to a completed past action as the reason for something.
Since the sentence starts with Eles, why is it ter escrito and not terem escrito?
Even though Eles (they) is the subject of selecionaram, Júlia is the one who wrote the essay, so the infinitive stays singular (ter) to match her. If you want to make it even clearer who wrote it, it is very common in Brazil to put the subject pronoun right before the infinitive: por ela ter escrito. If you used the plural form por terem escrito, the sentence would mean they selected Júlia because they had written a great essay.
Why is the participle escrito, without the usual -ido ending?
Escrever (to write) has an irregular past participle: escrito (written). Most -er verbs form their past participle with -ido (like comer → comido), but a small group of very common verbs use short irregular forms after ter. Other everyday verbs in this group include fazer → feito (done/made), dizer → dito (said), ver → visto (seen), and abrir → aberto (opened).
What is the a doing before Júlia in selecionaram a Júlia?
That a is simply the feminine definite article (the). In Brazilian Portuguese, it is standard in everyday speech to put o or a before people's first names when talking about them. Saying selecionaram Júlia without the article is also correct and sounds slightly more formal or written. (If you know Spanish, note that this is the article a rather than a preposition—if the person were a man named Pedro, it would be selecionaram o Pedro.)

Learn Eles selecionaram a Júlia por ter escrito uma ótima redação and more in Portuguese

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free