Breakdown of Mi hermana empezó a deshacer la cama mientras yo intentaba no apilar más libros sobre la silla.
Questions & Answers about Mi hermana empezó a deshacer la cama mientras yo intentaba no apilar más libros sobre la silla.
Why is it mi hermana and not la hermana mía?
Mi hermana is the normal, natural way to say my sister in Spanish.
Spanish usually puts the possessive before the noun:
- mi hermana = my sister
- mi libro = my book
The longer form with mío/mía/míos/mías is usually used for emphasis or contrast:
So in an ordinary sentence, mi hermana is exactly what you would expect.
Why does it say empezó a deshacer? Why is there an a after empezó?
After empezar, Spanish normally uses a before another verb in the infinitive.
Pattern:
- empezar a + infinitive = to begin to + verb
Examples:
So:
- empezó a deshacer la cama = she began to unmake the bed
This is a very common structure, and learners usually just need to memorize it as empezar a.
What does deshacer la cama mean exactly?
It literally means to undo the bed, but in natural English it usually means to unmake the bed or to pull the bed apart after it has been made.
It comes from:
The verb deshacer often means to undo, to take apart, or to reverse what was done:
- deshacer un nudo = to untie a knot
- deshacer la maleta = to unpack a suitcase
So here it suggests she was taking the bedcovers apart rather than making the bed neat.
Why is deshacer not reflexive here? Why not deshacerse?
Because deshacer and deshacerse are different verbs.
- deshacer = to undo, unmake, take apart
- deshacerse de = to get rid of
Examples:
- Deshizo la cama = She unmade the bed
- Se deshizo de los libros = She got rid of the books
In your sentence, the meaning is about physically undoing the bed, so deshacer la cama is correct.
Why is empezó in the preterite, but intentaba is in the imperfect?
This is one of the most important tense contrasts in Spanish.
- empezó (preterite) presents the action as a completed event or a clear starting point
- intentaba (imperfect) presents the action as ongoing, in progress, or background
So the sentence gives this picture:
- Mi hermana empezó... = a specific event happened: she started
- mientras yo intentaba... = at the same time, I was in the middle of trying
In English, this is often like:
- My sister started... while I was trying...
Spanish uses this contrast a lot to show foreground vs background in past narration.
Could intentaba be intenté instead?
Yes, grammatically it could be, but it would change the feel.
- intentaba = I was trying / I kept trying
- intenté = I tried
With intentaba, the action sounds ongoing and simultaneous with what the sister was doing.
With intenté, it would sound more like a separate, completed attempt:
- Mi hermana empezó a deshacer la cama mientras yo intenté... sounds less natural because mientras often sets up overlapping actions, and the imperfect fits that better.
So intentaba is the more natural choice if the idea is while I was trying...
How does mientras work here?
Why is it intentaba no apilar? Why does intentar use an infinitive?
Because intentar is followed directly by another verb in the infinitive.
Pattern:
- intentar + infinitive = to try to + verb
Examples:
So:
- intentaba no apilar más libros = I was trying not to stack more books
Notice there is no preposition between intentar and the infinitive. Unlike empezar a, intentar goes straight to the infinitive.
What exactly does no apilar más libros mean?
It means not to stack any more books or not to pile more books up.
Breakdown:
- apilar = to stack, pile up
- libros = books
- más = more
- no apilar más libros = not to stack more books
In context, it suggests there were already books on the chair, and the speaker was trying not to add even more.
A natural English translation would often be:
- trying not to pile any more books onto the chair or
- trying not to stack more books on the chair
Why use más libros and not something like otros libros?
Because más libros focuses on quantity: more books.
So:
- no apilar más libros = not to stack any more books
- no apilar otros libros would mean something more like not stacking different/other books, which is a different idea
Here the issue is quantity, not identity, so más is the right choice.
Why is it sobre la silla and not en la silla?
Because sobre means on top of, which fits the idea of stacking books onto a chair.
- sobre la silla = on the chair / on top of the chair
- en la silla = in the chair, or sometimes seated in the chair depending on context
Since books are being piled physically onto the surface of the chair, sobre is a good choice.
You may also hear:
- en la silla in some contexts
- encima de la silla = on top of the chair
But sobre la silla is clear and correct, and it sounds a bit more precise or slightly more literary than en la silla.
Why do we have the articles la in la cama and la silla?
Spanish often uses the definite article where English might use the, my, or sometimes no article at all, depending on context.
Here:
- la cama = the bed
- la silla = the chair
They refer to specific, known objects in the situation. Even if English might sometimes say bed or chair more loosely, Spanish commonly uses the article with concrete nouns in a scene like this.
Also, in Spanish, the article is very frequent with everyday objects:
- cerró la puerta = she closed the door
- levantó la mano = he raised his hand
So la cama and la silla sound completely normal.
Is there anything special about the word order in this sentence?
The word order is quite normal.
Main structure:
This is basically:
- subject + verb + complement
- while
- subject + verb + complement
Spanish word order is often flexible, but this sentence uses a straightforward order that matches the flow of the story clearly.
You could move parts around for emphasis, but the original version sounds natural and easy to follow.
Is apilar a common everyday verb? Could another verb be used?
Yes, apilar is a real and correct verb, but it is a bit more specific than a more general verb like poner.
- apilar = to stack, pile up neatly or in a heap
- poner = to put
- dejar = to leave
- amontonar = to heap up, pile up messily
So:
- apilar más libros sobre la silla suggests stacking books one on top of another
- poner más libros sobre la silla would just mean putting more books there, without the idea of a stack
So apilar is a good choice if the sentence wants that image of books accumulating in a pile.
How would this sentence sound if both actions were just described as ongoing background actions?
Then Spanish would likely use the imperfect for both verbs.
That would mean:
- My sister was unmaking the bed while I was trying not to stack more books on the chair.
The original sentence is different because empezó highlights the moment when the sister started the action. That gives the sentence a more specific narrative event.
So the original version focuses on:
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from Mi hermana empezó a deshacer la cama mientras yo intentaba no apilar más libros sobre la silla to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions