Breakdown of A Ana não gosta de sementes na salada, por isso tira as sementes do tomate e deita a casca fora.
Questions & Answers about A Ana não gosta de sementes na salada, por isso tira as sementes do tomate e deita a casca fora.
Why is there an article before the name in A Ana?
In European Portuguese, it is very common to use the definite article before a person’s first name:
- A Ana
- O João
- A Maria
So A Ana simply means Ana.
This is much more common in Portuguese than in English, where we normally do not say the Ana. In Portugal, using the article with names is very natural in everyday speech and also common in informal writing.
Why is it não gosta de and not just não gosta?
Because the verb gostar normally requires the preposition de.
So:
- gostar de sementes = to like seeds
- não gostar de sementes = not to like seeds
This is just how the verb works in Portuguese. A native English speaker often wants to translate directly from like, but in Portuguese you usually need to remember:
- gostar de + noun
- gostar de + infinitive
Examples:
- Gosto de café. = I like coffee.
- Ela gosta de cozinhar. = She likes cooking / She likes to cook.
What does na salada mean grammatically?
Na is a contraction of em + a:
- em = in
- a = the
- na = in the
So:
- na salada = in the salad
Portuguese very often contracts prepositions with articles:
- em + o = no
- em + a = na
- de + o = do
- de + a = da
This is something you will see constantly.
What does por isso mean, and how is it used?
Why is it tira as sementes do tomate? What is do?
Do is a contraction of de + o:
- de = from / of
- o = the
- do = from the / of the
So:
- do tomate = from the tomato
And the whole part means:
- tira as sementes do tomate = she removes the seeds from the tomato
Again, contractions like this are standard and required in normal Portuguese.
Why is tomate masculine here?
Because the noun tomate is masculine in Portuguese:
- o tomate
So when it combines with de, you get:
- de + o tomate = do tomate
Grammatical gender in Portuguese does not always match what an English speaker might expect, so it is best to learn nouns together with their article:
- o tomate
- a salada
- a casca
- a semente
What is the difference between tirar and deitar fora in this sentence?
They describe two different actions:
- tirar = to remove / take out
- deitar fora = to throw away / discard
So Ana first:
Then she:
- deita a casca fora = throws the skin away
A useful way to see it is:
- tirar = take something out of somewhere
- deitar fora = get rid of something
Why does Portuguese say deita a casca fora? Why is fora at the end?
Because deitar fora is a very common verbal expression meaning to throw away.
In Portuguese, expressions like this often allow the object to come between the verb and the final particle:
- deitar fora a casca
- deitar a casca fora
Both patterns can occur, but deitar a casca fora is very natural.
So here:
- deita = throws
- a casca = the skin/peel
- fora = away/out
Together: throws the skin away
In Portugal, deitar fora is the usual everyday verb for throw away. In Brazilian Portuguese, learners will often hear jogar fora instead.
Could you also say deita fora a casca?
Yes, that is also possible.
With deitar fora, both of these are natural:
- deita a casca fora
- deita fora a casca
The version in your sentence is very common and idiomatic.
If you replace the noun with a pronoun, the structure changes again, for example:
- deita-a fora = throws it away
That is worth noticing later, but for now the key point is that deitar fora works as a fixed expression meaning to throw away.
Why is it a casca in the singular, but as sementes in the plural?
Does casca mean skin or peel?
It can mean either, depending on context.
For food, casca often means:
- skin
- peel
- rind
- shell
Examples:
In this sentence, skin is probably the most natural translation in English, but peel may also fit depending on how literally you want to describe it.
Why is sementes repeated instead of using a pronoun?
Portuguese could use a pronoun, but repeating the noun is often clearer and completely natural.
Here you have:
The repetition helps keep the sentence clear and explicit.
A pronoun version would be possible in the right context, but it would be less straightforward for a learner. Portuguese often repeats nouns where English might prefer a pronoun.
Is this sentence in the present tense? Why?
Yes, it is in the present tense:
- não gosta
- tira
- deita
This kind of present tense is often used for:
- a habitual action
- a general fact about someone’s behaviour
So the sentence suggests something like:
- Ana doesn’t like seeds in salad, so she removes them from the tomato and throws the skin away.
It sounds like a normal habit or usual way of preparing salad, not necessarily a one-time action happening right now.
How would this sound in more natural English word order?
A very natural English version would be:
- Ana doesn’t like seeds in her salad, so she removes the seeds from the tomato and throws the skin away.
A couple of points:
- English would often say in her salad rather than just in the salad, depending on context.
- deitar fora is best translated naturally as throw away, not word-for-word.
So when reading Portuguese, it helps to translate for meaning, not structure.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from A Ana não gosta de sementes na salada, por isso tira as sementes do tomate e deita a casca fora to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions