Breakdown of Minha filha quer usar sandália preta, porque o sapato fechado não é confortável.
Questions & Answers about Minha filha quer usar sandália preta, porque o sapato fechado não é confortável.
Why is it minha filha and not meu filha?
Because minha has to agree with filha, the thing being possessed.
In Portuguese, possessive words like meu / minha / meus / minhas agree in gender and number with the noun that follows:
- meu filho = my son
- minha filha = my daughter
- meus filhos = my sons / my children
- minhas filhas = my daughters
So since filha is feminine singular, minha is the correct form.
Could I also say a minha filha instead of minha filha?
Yes. In Brazilian Portuguese, both are possible:
- Minha filha quer...
- A minha filha quer...
The article a before a possessive is very common in Brazil, especially in speech. Leaving it out is also correct and often sounds a bit more direct or neutral.
With family words like mãe, pai, filho, filha, omitting the article is especially common.
Why does the sentence use two verbs: quer usar?
This is a very common structure in Portuguese.
- quer = wants
- usar = to wear / to use
After a conjugated verb like querer, the next verb normally stays in the infinitive:
- quero comer = I want to eat
- ela quer sair = she wants to go out
- minha filha quer usar = my daughter wants to wear
So quer usar works just like English wants to wear.
Can usar really mean to wear?
Yes. In Portuguese, usar is very commonly used for clothes, shoes, and accessories.
Examples:
- usar sandália = to wear sandals
- usar vestido = to wear a dress
- usar óculos = to wear glasses
Even though usar also means to use, it is perfectly normal for clothing.
Another common verb is vestir, but usar is often more natural for talking about what someone wears, especially items like shoes, accessories, or particular styles.
Why is it sandália preta and not sandália preto?
Because adjectives usually agree with the noun in gender and number.
- sandália is feminine singular
- so the adjective becomes preta
Compare:
- sandália preta
- sapato preto
- sandálias pretas
- sapatos pretos
The same happens with sapato fechado:
- sapato is masculine singular
- so fechado is masculine singular too
Why is there no article in usar sandália preta? Could I say usar uma sandália preta?
Yes, but the meaning or feel changes a bit.
After usar, Portuguese often leaves out the article when talking generally about clothing or footwear:
- usar saia
- usar camisa branca
- usar sandália preta
This sounds like talking about the type/style of thing someone wants to wear.
If you say usar uma sandália preta, it sounds more like one particular black sandal item or a more specific instance.
If you say usar a sandália preta, that usually means a specific black sandal already known in the conversation.
So in this sentence, usar sandália preta sounds natural because it focuses on the kind of footwear she wants to wear.
What exactly does sapato fechado mean?
Literally, it means closed shoe, but in natural English it usually refers to a shoe that covers the foot more fully, especially a closed-toe shoe.
It contrasts with open footwear like:
- sandália = sandal
- chinelo = flip-flop / slipper
- sapato fechado = closed shoe
So the idea is that she wants sandals because closed shoes are not comfortable.
Why is it o sapato fechado with o? Is it talking about one specific shoe?
Not necessarily.
In Portuguese, the definite article is often used where English might be more general. So o sapato fechado can mean:
- the specific closed shoe being considered, or
- closed shoes as a category in this situation
Portuguese often uses the singular definite form to talk about a type of thing more naturally than English does.
So here o sapato fechado can be understood as closed shoes / closed footwear in general, not only one single shoe.
Why does confortável not change like preta and fechado?
Because some Portuguese adjectives have the same form for masculine and feminine in the singular.
Confortável is one of them:
- o sapato é confortável
- a sandália é confortável
The form stays the same in both masculine and feminine singular.
Only the plural changes:
- os sapatos são confortáveis
- as sandálias são confortáveis
So preta changes because that adjective has masculine/feminine forms, but confortável does not.
Why is it não é confortável instead of não está confortável?
- ser is often used for general characteristics
- estar is often used for temporary states or how something is at the moment
Here, não é confortável means the closed shoe is generally not comfortable.
If you said não está confortável, it would sound more like:
- it does not feel comfortable right now
- in this moment or in this situation, it is uncomfortable
So não é confortável is the more natural choice if you mean that this kind of shoe is not comfortable for her.
Why is porque one word here?
Because here it means because, introducing the reason.
- porque = because
Portuguese has several similar-looking forms:
- porque = because
- por que = why / for what reason
- por quê = why, usually at the end of a question
- o porquê = the reason
In this sentence, the second part gives the reason, so porque is the correct form.
Is the comma before porque necessary?
Not really. In a sentence like this, many people would write it without the comma:
The comma can appear in real-life writing because speakers may feel a pause there, or they may treat the second part as a stronger explanation. But if you are unsure, leaving the comma out is often the safer default in a straightforward because sentence.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from Minha filha quer usar sandália preta, porque o sapato fechado não é confortável to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions