Breakdown of Meine Mutter legt die Handcreme in ihre Tasche, bevor sie zur Arbeit geht.
Questions & Answers about Meine Mutter legt die Handcreme in ihre Tasche, bevor sie zur Arbeit geht.
Why is it legt here? What does legen mean?
Legen means to lay, to put down, or more generally to place something somewhere.
In this sentence, legt is the 3rd person singular form, matching meine Mutter:
- ich lege
- du legst
- er/sie/es legt
So Meine Mutter legt ... = My mother puts/places ...
German often uses different verbs for put, depending on the kind of placement:
- legen = lay/place something horizontally or generally put it somewhere
- stellen = stand/place something upright
- setzen = set someone/something into a sitting position
With something like Handcreme, legen sounds natural.
Why is it die Handcreme?
Die Handcreme is the direct object of the sentence — it is the thing being put into the bag.
The verb legen takes an object in the accusative case, and die Handcreme is already the accusative form here.
This noun is feminine:
- nominative: die Handcreme
- accusative: die Handcreme
Because feminine nouns often look the same in nominative and accusative, the form does not change.
Why is it in ihre Tasche and not in ihrer Tasche?
This is a very common question because in is a two-way preposition.
With in, you use:
- accusative when there is movement toward a destination
- dative when there is location with no movement
Here, the cream is being moved into the bag, so German uses the accusative:
- in ihre Tasche = into her bag
Compare:
Sie legt die Handcreme in ihre Tasche.
She puts the hand cream into her bag.
→ movement → accusativeDie Handcreme ist in ihrer Tasche.
The hand cream is in her bag.
→ location → dative
Why is it ihre Tasche?
Ihre means her here, and it agrees with Tasche, which is a feminine noun.
Because Tasche is feminine and the phrase is in the accusative, the form is:
- ihre Tasche
Here is the pattern:
- nominative feminine: ihre Tasche
- accusative feminine: ihre Tasche
- dative feminine: ihrer Tasche
So the reason it is ihre and not ihrer is that this phrase is accusative, not dative.
What does bevor do to the word order?
Bevor means before and introduces a subordinate clause.
In German subordinate clauses, the conjugated verb goes to the end. That is why you get:
- bevor sie zur Arbeit geht
not:
- bevor sie geht zur Arbeit
So the structure is:
- main clause: Meine Mutter legt die Handcreme in ihre Tasche
- subordinate clause: bevor sie zur Arbeit geht
This verb-final pattern is one of the most important features of German subordinate clauses.
Why is it zur Arbeit instead of zu der Arbeit?
Zur is just the contraction of:
- zu der → zur
So:
- zur Arbeit = to work
This contraction is very common and usually preferred.
A few useful contractions:
- zu dem → zum
- an dem → am
- in dem → im
- bei dem → beim
So zur Arbeit gehen is the normal expression for to go to work.
Why is it geht in the present tense if the action might happen in the future?
German uses the present tense very often for things that happen:
- regularly
- habitually
- in the near future
So bevor sie zur Arbeit geht can mean:
- before she goes to work
- before she is going to work
- before she leaves for work
This is normal German usage. You do not need a future tense here.
Who does sie refer to? Could it mean the mother or the hand cream?
Grammatically, sie could in theory refer to either meine Mutter or die Handcreme, because both are feminine.
But in real usage, context makes the meaning clear. Here:
- zur Arbeit geht strongly suggests a person
- hand cream does not go to work
So the listener naturally understands sie as meine Mutter.
This is a good example of how German pronouns can sometimes be grammatically ambiguous but still perfectly clear in context.
Why is Arbeit not capitalized because it is after a preposition? Or rather, why is it capitalized at all?
In German, all nouns are capitalized, no matter where they appear in the sentence.
So:
- Mutter
- Handcreme
- Tasche
- Arbeit
are all capitalized because they are nouns.
This is very different from English and is something learners have to get used to.
Why is the main clause word order Meine Mutter legt ... but the subordinate clause ends with geht?
German has different word-order rules for main clauses and subordinate clauses.
In a main clause, the conjugated verb usually comes in second position:
- Meine Mutter legt die Handcreme in ihre Tasche.
Here, Meine Mutter is in the first position, so legt must come second.
In a subordinate clause introduced by a word like bevor, the conjugated verb goes to the end:
- bevor sie zur Arbeit geht
So the sentence shows both important patterns at once:
- main clause: verb in second position
- subordinate clause: verb at the end
Could you also say bevor sie auf die Arbeit geht?
In some regions, especially in colloquial speech, people do say auf die Arbeit. But standard German usually prefers:
- zur Arbeit gehen
So for learners, zur Arbeit gehen is the safest and most widely accepted form.
Compare:
- Sie geht zur Arbeit. = standard / neutral
- Sie geht auf die Arbeit. = regional / colloquial in some areas
Is Handcreme one word because German likes compound nouns?
Yes. German very often combines nouns into a single compound noun.
Here:
- Hand = hand
- Creme = cream
Together:
- Handcreme = hand cream
This is extremely common in German. Some examples:
- Hausaufgabe = homework
- Kühlschrank = refrigerator
- Zahnbürste = toothbrush
When learning German, it helps to get used to seeing one long noun where English uses two or more words.
Could the sentence be written with the clauses in the opposite order?
Yes. You could also say:
- Bevor sie zur Arbeit geht, legt meine Mutter die Handcreme in ihre Tasche.
That means the same thing.
But notice what happens in the main clause after the subordinate clause comes first:
- Bevor sie zur Arbeit geht, legt meine Mutter ...
The verb legt comes immediately after the subordinate clause. This is because the whole subordinate clause counts as the first element, so the verb still has to be in second position in the main clause.
That is another very important German word-order rule.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Meine Mutter legt die Handcreme in ihre Tasche, bevor sie zur Arbeit geht to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions