Breakdown of Gegen den Husten hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon, aber meine Mutter vertraut eher auf ein altes Hausmittel.
Questions & Answers about Gegen den Husten hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon, aber meine Mutter vertraut eher auf ein altes Hausmittel.
Why does the sentence start with Gegen den Husten instead of the subject?
German main clauses often move one element to the first position to set the topic or focus. Here, Gegen den Husten is placed first to frame the sentence as as for the cough / for the cough.
Because German main clauses still keep the finite verb in second position, the verb comes next:
Gegen den Husten hilft ...
That means the subject can appear later:
Gegen den Husten hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon.
A more neutral order would be:
Ein Hustenbonbon hilft mir manchmal gegen den Husten.
Both are grammatical, but the emphasis is slightly different.
Why is it den Husten and not dem Husten?
Because gegen always takes the accusative case.
- der Husten = nominative
- den Husten = accusative
So:
- gegen den Husten = against the cough
This is a fixed rule for the preposition gegen.
What does gegen mean here?
Literally, gegen means against. In health-related contexts, German often uses gegen where English might say for:
- etwas gegen Kopfschmerzen = something for headaches
- Medizin gegen Husten = medicine for a cough
So Gegen den Husten is literally against the cough, but in natural English it often corresponds to for the cough.
Why is it mir and not mich?
Because the verb helfen takes a dative object, not an accusative object.
- jemandem helfen = to help someone
So:
- mir = to me
- mich = me
In this sentence, mir is correct because the cough drop is helping me in the dative sense:
Ein Hustenbonbon hilft mir.
Other examples:
- Kannst du mir helfen?
- Das Medikament hilft ihm.
What is the subject of hilft?
The subject is ein Hustenbonbon.
That is why the verb is singular:
- ein Hustenbonbon hilft
Even though mir comes right after the verb, mir is not the subject. It is the dative object.
So the structure is basically:
- Gegen den Husten = prepositional phrase
- hilft = verb
- mir = dative object
- manchmal = adverb
- ein Hustenbonbon = subject
This is very normal in German, where the subject does not have to come before the verb.
Why is manchmal placed there?
German adverbs are fairly flexible, especially in the middle of the sentence. Here, manchmal fits naturally after the dative pronoun mir:
hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon
This sounds natural because short pronouns like mir often come early, and time words like manchmal often come after them.
You could also hear other orders, depending on emphasis, but this version is very idiomatic.
Is Hustenbonbon really one word?
Yes. German very often combines nouns into one compound word.
- Husten = cough
- Bonbon = candy / lozenge
So:
- das Hustenbonbon = cough drop / cough lozenge
In German, the last part usually determines the gender. Since das Bonbon is neuter, das Hustenbonbon is also neuter.
Why does the sentence use aber and then normal word order?
Because aber is a coordinating conjunction. It connects two main clauses and does not send the verb to the end.
So you get:
..., aber meine Mutter vertraut eher auf ein altes Hausmittel.
This is normal main-clause word order, with the verb in second position.
Compare that with a subordinating conjunction like weil, which would send the verb to the end:
- ..., weil meine Mutter eher auf ein altes Hausmittel vertraut.
So aber behaves more like English but.
What does eher mean here?
Eher means something like rather, more readily, or more inclined to.
In this sentence, it suggests preference or tendency:
- meine Mutter vertraut eher auf ein altes Hausmittel
This means she tends to rely more on an old home remedy, rather than on something else.
So eher adds a comparison, even if the comparison is only implied.
Why is it vertraut auf ein altes Hausmittel?
Here, the sentence uses the expression auf etwas vertrauen, which means to rely on or to place trust in something.
That construction uses auf + accusative, so:
- auf ein altes Hausmittel
This is worth noticing because vertrauen can also appear without auf and then takes the dative:
- jemandem vertrauen = to trust someone
- einer Methode vertrauen = to trust a method
But auf etwas vertrauen is also common and often has a sense of relying on something.
Why is it altes and not alte?
Because Hausmittel is a neuter noun:
- das Hausmittel
After ein with a neuter singular noun, the adjective takes -es in nominative and accusative singular:
- ein altes Hausmittel
So the ending matches the grammar of:
- ein
- neuter singular noun
- here after auf, so accusative singular
That is why altes is correct.
What exactly does Hausmittel mean?
Hausmittel means home remedy or traditional household remedy.
It usually suggests something familiar, old-fashioned, or passed down in the family, such as tea, honey, onion syrup, or similar simple remedies.
So ein altes Hausmittel has a slightly traditional feel, not just any medicine.
Could I also say Ein Hustenbonbon hilft mir manchmal gegen den Husten?
Yes. That would be completely correct.
It simply changes the focus:
- Gegen den Husten hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon puts the cough first as the topic
- Ein Hustenbonbon hilft mir manchmal gegen den Husten puts the cough drop first as the topic
German allows this kind of flexibility much more than English does.
What is the function of the comma?
The comma separates two main clauses:
- Gegen den Husten hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon
- aber meine Mutter vertraut eher auf ein altes Hausmittel
In German, when two full main clauses are joined by a conjunction like aber, a comma is normally used.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Gegen den Husten hilft mir manchmal ein Hustenbonbon, aber meine Mutter vertraut eher auf ein altes Hausmittel to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions