Breakdown of Ils y pensent depuis longtemps, et ils vont en parler à leurs amis.
Questions & Answers about Ils y pensent depuis longtemps, et ils vont en parler à leurs amis.
What is y doing in Ils y pensent? Does it mean there here?
Here y does not mean there in a literal place sense.
With penser à, French often replaces à + thing/idea with y:
- penser à quelque chose = to think about something
- y penser = to think about it
So Ils y pensent means They are thinking about it.
Fuller versions would be:
- Ils pensent à cela
- Ils pensent à ça (more informal)
So yes, y can sometimes mean there, but in this sentence it stands for à it/about it.
Why is it penser à here? What is the difference between penser à and penser de?
This is a very common question because English uses think about and think of in several ways.
In French:
- penser à = to think about, to have something in mind
- penser de = to think of, in the sense of to have an opinion about
So:
- Ils pensent à ce problème = They are thinking about that problem.
- Que pensent-ils de ce problème ? = What do they think of that problem?
In your sentence, the meaning is they have this thing in mind / they are thinking about it, so French uses penser à, which is why y appears.
Can y replace a person too?
Usually, no.
Y normally replaces à + thing, à + idea, or sometimes à + place. It does not normally replace à + person.
So:
- Ils pensent à leur projet → Ils y pensent
- Ils pensent à Marie → Ils pensent à elle
not normally Ils y pensent
This is an important rule for both y and en: they usually replace things or ideas, not people.
What does en replace in ils vont en parler?
The verb pattern here is:
- parler de quelque chose à quelqu'un = to talk about something to someone
So:
A fuller version would be:
- Ils vont parler de cela à leurs amis
- Ils vont parler de ça à leurs amis (more informal)
So in this sentence:
Even though both become it in English, French uses different pronouns because the prepositions are different: à → y, de → en.
Can en replace a person?
Normally, no, not in standard careful French.
For people, French usually keeps a stressed pronoun after de:
For things and ideas, en is the normal replacement:
- Ils parlent de ce plan → Ils en parlent
So, as a general learning rule:
- y and en usually replace things, ideas, or places
- for people, use forms like à lui, à elle, d’eux, de lui, etc.
Why is it ils vont en parler and not ils en vont parler?
Because en belongs to the infinitive parler, not to vont.
French pronoun placement works like this:
- With a simple conjugated verb, the pronoun goes before the conjugated verb:
Ils y pensent - With a construction like aller + infinitive, the pronoun usually goes before the infinitive it belongs to:
Ils vont en parler
Compare:
- Je le fais = I do it
- Je vais le faire = I am going to do it
So:
Why is pensent in the present tense with depuis longtemps?
Because in French, the present tense is used for something that started in the past and is still continuing now.
So:
literally uses the present, but in English we often translate it as:
- They have been thinking about it for a long time
This is very typical with depuis:
- J’habite ici depuis deux ans = I have been living here for two years
- Elle attend depuis midi = She has been waiting since noon
So depuis longtemps tells you the action has been going on for a long time up to now.
Why use ils vont parler instead of the simple future ils parleront?
Both are possible, but they are not exactly the same in tone.
- Ils vont en parler = They are going to talk about it
This often feels more immediate, more planned, or closer to the present. - Ils en parleront = They will talk about it
This is a more general future statement.
In everyday spoken French, aller + infinitive is very common.
So the sentence uses a very natural conversational future form.
Why is there à in à leurs amis?
Because parler can take both:
- the topic: de quelque chose
- the person being spoken to: à quelqu'un
So the full structure is:
- parler de quelque chose à quelqu'un
In this sentence:
- en = about it = the topic
- à leurs amis = to their friends = the listeners
So:
- Ils vont en parler à leurs amis
= They are going to talk about it to their friends / talk to their friends about it
Why is it leurs amis and not leur amis or ses amis?
Because leurs agrees with the noun amis, which is plural.
French possessive adjectives agree with the thing possessed, not with the number of owners.
So:
- leur ami = their friend
- leurs amis = their friends
And:
- ses amis = his/her friends
- leurs amis = their friends
Since the subject is ils and the noun amis is plural, leurs amis is the correct form.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Ils y pensent depuis longtemps, et ils vont en parler à leurs amis to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions