Question 1

Why is it con el que instead of just que?

Accepted Answer

In English, we often end a phrase with a preposition, like 'the hammer the man breaks the glass with'. In Spanish, a preposition cannot dangle at the end. It must come before the relative pronoun. So, you literally say 'the hammer with which the man breaks the glass'. Since martillo is masculine and singular, we use el que after the preposition con, giving us con el que.

Question 2

Could I use con quien instead of con el que here?

Accepted Answer

No. The words quien and quienes are only used to refer to people ('who' or 'whom'). Because el martillo is an object, you must use el que.

Question 3

What if the sentence was about a feminine noun, like la herramienta (the tool), instead of el martillo?

Accepted Answer

If the noun were feminine, you would change the relative pronoun to match its gender. Instead of con el que, you would say con la que to match the feminine noun (la herramienta con la que el hombre...).

Question 4

Does el cristal mean 'crystal' here?

Accepted Answer

It can mean 'crystal', but in everyday Spanish, el cristal is very commonly used to mean 'glass', especially window glass or the glass of a display case. For the general material of glass, you will also often hear el vidrio.

Question 5

Why use es for no es auténtico instead of está?

Accepted Answer

We use ser (here as es) to talk about the inherent identity or defining characteristics of a thing. Being authentic or real is a fundamental, permanent quality of this hammer, not a temporary state or condition.

El martillo con el que el hombre rompe el cristal no es auténtico.

Breakdown of El martillo con el que el hombre rompe el cristal no es auténtico.

Questions & Answers about El martillo con el que el hombre rompe el cristal no es auténtico.

Learn El martillo con el que el hombre rompe el cristal no es auténtico and more in Spanish