Breakdown of hontou ha, eigakan ni ikitai desu ga, kyou ha okane ga arimasen.
Questions & Answers about hontou ha, eigakan ni ikitai desu ga, kyou ha okane ga arimasen.
What does 本当は mean here, and why is は used after 本当?
本当は means something like actually, to tell the truth, or if I’m being honest.
The は adds a contrastive feeling. It is not just saying truth as a noun; it is more like:
- as for the truth
- actually
- the reality is...
In this sentence, 本当は suggests a contrast between what the speaker wants and the situation that prevents it.
So the feeling is:
- Actually, I want to go to the movie theater, but...
Without は, 本当 by itself would not sound natural in this role.
Why are there two は particles in the sentence: 本当は and 今日は?
They are doing slightly different but related jobs.
- 本当は sets up a contrastive frame: actually / in truth
- 今日は means as for today or today, at least
Japanese often uses は to mark a topic or create contrast.
In this sentence, the speaker is contrasting:
- their true desire: 映画館に行きたいです
- today’s reality: 今日はお金がありません
So 今日は can imply something like:
- I don’t have money today
(maybe on another day I might)
This use of は is very common when the speaker wants to highlight a particular condition or time.
Why is に used after 映画館?
The particle に marks the destination of movement.
Since 行く means to go, the place you go to is commonly marked with に:
- 学校に行く = go to school
- 日本に行く = go to Japan
- 映画館に行く = go to the movie theater
You may also sometimes see へ with 行く. Both can work for destinations, but:
- に focuses more directly on the destination
- へ emphasizes the direction toward it
In this sentence, 映画館に行きたい is the most natural standard phrasing.
How does 行きたい mean want to go?
行きたい is formed from the verb 行く.
The pattern is:
- verb stem + たい
For 行く:
- 行きます is the polite form
- the stem is 行き
- 行きたい = want to go
So:
- 食べたい = want to eat
- 見たい = want to see
- 帰りたい = want to go home
A useful point: たい behaves grammatically like an い-adjective, not like a normal verb after it is formed.
Why is it 行きたいです and not just 行きたい?
Both are correct, but the politeness level is different.
- 行きたい = plain style
- 行きたいです = polite style
Even though たい behaves like an い-adjective, Japanese often adds です to make it polite:
- 嬉しいです
- 忙しいです
- 行きたいです
So 行きたいです is a polite way to say I want to go.
If たい acts like an い-adjective, can it be negative or past like an adjective too?
Yes. That is an important grammar point.
Because たい behaves like an い-adjective, it changes like one:
- 行きたい = want to go
- 行きたくない = do not want to go
- 行きたかった = wanted to go
- 行きたくなかった = did not want to go
Polite versions are also possible:
- 行きたくないです
- 行きたかったです
So in this sentence, 行きたいです is part of that same adjective-like pattern.
What does が mean here? Is it just but?
Here, が is a conjunction meaning but or although.
It connects the two parts:
- 映画館に行きたいです
- 今日はお金がありません
So the sentence means:
- I want to go to the movie theater, but I don’t have money today.
A nuance point: sentence-linking が often sounds a little softer or less abrupt than a strong English but. It can feel gentle and conversational.
Japanese also commonly uses:
- けど
- けれども
- でも (at the start of a new sentence more often)
In this sentence, が is very natural and polite.
Why is it お金がありません instead of お金はありません?
お金がありません is the neutral, standard way to say I don’t have money.
Here, が marks お金 as the thing that does not exist / is not present.
- お金がある = there is money / I have money
- お金がない = there is no money / I don’t have money
If you say お金はありません, the は adds contrast or emphasis, like:
- As for money, I don’t have any
- I may have other things, but money is what I don’t have
So がありません is the more straightforward choice here.
Why does Japanese use あります / ありません for money instead of a verb meaning to have?
Japanese often expresses possession by using ある or いる, which literally relate to existence.
For inanimate things, use ある:
- お金がある = money exists → I have money
- 時間がある = time exists → I have time
For animate beings, use いる:
- 犬がいる = there is a dog / I have a dog
So お金がありません literally feels like money does not exist, but in natural English it means I don’t have money.
Is ありません more formal than ないです?
Yes.
Both are polite, but they have slightly different tones:
- お金がないです = polite, common in everyday speech
- お金がありません = more formal, more textbook-like, often a bit more careful
In this sentence, ありません matches the polite tone created by 行きたいです and が.
So the whole sentence sounds neat and polite.
Where is the subject? Why doesn’t the sentence say I?
Japanese often leaves out the subject when it is obvious from context.
In English, you usually need I:
- I want to go...
- I don’t have money...
In Japanese, if the speaker is clearly talking about themselves, 私は is often omitted.
So the full idea could be:
- 私は本当は映画館に行きたいですが、今日はお金がありません。
But in natural Japanese, leaving out 私は is very normal.
Is the word order fixed, or could parts of the sentence move around?
Japanese word order is more flexible than English, as long as the particles stay correct.
This sentence’s order is very natural:
- 本当は、映画館に行きたいですが、今日はお金がありません。
But you could move some elements for emphasis. For example:
- 今日は、本当は映画館に行きたいですが、お金がありません。
That puts more focus on today first.
Even so, the original version is smoother and easier for learners to follow. Japanese lets you move pieces around more than English, but not every possible order sounds equally natural.
Does 本当は suggest that the speaker wants to do something different from what will actually happen?
Yes, very often.
本当は frequently introduces a hidden wish, true feeling, or reality that contrasts with what follows.
In this sentence, the speaker is saying:
- their true wish: go to the movie theater
- the obstacle: no money today
So it can imply:
That contrastive feeling is one reason 本当は is used so often in everyday speech.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from hontou ha, eigakan ni ikitai desu ga, kyou ha okane ga arimasen to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions