Breakdown of Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen, entscheidet meine Schwester erst am Abend.
Questions & Answers about Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen, entscheidet meine Schwester erst am Abend.
What does ob mean here?
Here ob means whether.
It introduces an indirect yes/no question, not a normal statement. The idea is:
- Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen = Whether we cook vegan or only vegetarian today
German often uses ob where English uses whether or sometimes if.
Examples:
- Ich weiß nicht, ob er kommt. = I don’t know whether he’s coming.
- Sie entscheidet, ob wir gehen. = She decides whether we go.
In your sentence, the speaker is talking about the decision itself, not asking a direct question.
Why is kochen at the end of the first part?
Because ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen is a subordinate clause.
In German subordinate clauses, the conjugated verb usually goes to the end. Here, kochen is the conjugated verb for wir.
So the order is:
- ob
- wir
- heute
- vegan oder nur vegetarisch
- kochen
That final verb position is one of the most important patterns in German subordinate clauses.
Why does the sentence say entscheidet meine Schwester instead of meine Schwester entscheidet?
Because the sentence begins with the subordinate clause, and that whole clause takes up the first position in the sentence.
German main clauses follow the verb-second rule. That means the conjugated verb of the main clause must come in the second position.
Structure here:
- Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen = first position
- entscheidet = verb in second position
- meine Schwester = subject
- erst am Abend
So even though meine Schwester is the subject, it comes after the verb because the first slot is already occupied.
What exactly is the first clause doing in the sentence?
The first clause, Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen, is a content clause. It expresses what is being decided.
You can think of it as the thing the sister is deciding:
- She decides whether we cook vegan or only vegetarian today.
A more neutral word order would be:
- Meine Schwester entscheidet erst am Abend, ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen.
That version may be easier to recognize at first, because the main clause comes first.
Why is there a comma after kochen?
Because in German, a subordinate clause is separated from the main clause by a comma.
So:
- Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen, entscheidet meine Schwester erst am Abend.
This comma is required in standard German.
What does erst am Abend mean here?
Erst here means something like not until.
So:
- erst am Abend = not until the evening
It suggests that the decision happens relatively late.
Compare:
- am Abend = in the evening
- erst am Abend = not until the evening
So the sentence has the nuance that the sister won’t decide before then.
Why is German using the present tense here, even though the cooking may happen later?
Because German often uses the present tense to talk about the near future, just like English often does.
So:
- wir kochen heute can mean we are cooking today or we will cook today, depending on context.
You do not need a future form here. The word heute already gives the time reference.
What is the difference between vegan and vegetarisch, and what does nur add?
- vegan = vegan
- vegetarisch = vegetarian
The word nur means only / just.
So:
- vegan oder nur vegetarisch means vegan or only vegetarian
That suggests a contrast:
- vegan is the stricter option
- nur vegetarisch is the less strict option
The nur adds a nuance like:
- maybe not fully vegan, but at least vegetarian
Is ob ... oder ... a special pattern?
Yes. Ob often introduces an indirect question about which of two possibilities is true.
So:
- ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen
means:
- whether we cook vegan or only vegetarian today
The oder gives the alternatives inside the ob-clause.
This is very common in German:
- Ich weiß nicht, ob er heute oder morgen kommt.
- Sie überlegt, ob sie bleibt oder geht.
Could I put the main clause first instead?
Is am Abend the same as abends?
Not exactly.
- am Abend = in the evening / this evening in a specific situation
- abends = in the evenings or in the evening as a habitual/general time
In your sentence:
- erst am Abend refers to this particular evening, so am Abend is the natural choice.
If you said abends, it could sound more habitual, as if this is what she generally does.
Why is there no article before vegan or vegetarisch?
Because here vegan and vegetarisch are being used like adverbial/predicative descriptions of how you cook, not as nouns.
So:
- vegan kochen = to cook vegan food / to cook in a vegan way
- vegetarisch kochen = to cook vegetarian food / to cook in a vegetarian way
This is normal in German. You do not need an article here.
What is the subject of the whole sentence?
The grammatical subject of the main clause is meine Schwester.
That is why the verb entscheidet is singular:
- entscheidet meine Schwester
Inside the subordinate clause, the subject is wir:
- ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen
So the sentence contains two different clauses, each with its own subject:
- wir in the subordinate clause
- meine Schwester in the main clause
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Ob wir heute vegan oder nur vegetarisch kochen, entscheidet meine Schwester erst am Abend to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions