Im September brauche ich meiner Schwägerin nicht noch einmal zu schreiben, weil sie immer sofort antwortet.

Elon.io is an online learning platform
We have an entire course teaching German grammar and vocabulary.

Start learning German now

Questions & Answers about Im September brauche ich meiner Schwägerin nicht noch einmal zu schreiben, weil sie immer sofort antwortet.

Why is it im September and not just September?

Im September means in September.

Here, im is a contraction of in dem:

  • in demim

With months, German normally uses in + dative article, so:

  • im September
  • im Januar
  • im Mai

So im September is the standard way to say in September.

Why does the sentence say brauche ich instead of ich brauche?

Because German main clauses follow the verb-second rule.

The first element in the sentence is Im September, so the conjugated verb has to come next:

  • Im September brauche ich ...

If the sentence began with the subject instead, then you would get:

  • Ich brauche im September ...

Both are grammatical, but the version with Im September first puts extra focus on the time.

How does brauchen ... zu schreiben work here?

Here brauchen is used with zu + infinitive:

  • brauchen, ... zu schreiben

In this structure, brauchen means something like to need to.

Because it is negated here:

  • brauche ... nicht ... zu schreiben

the meaning is:

  • do not need to write

This is a very common pattern in German:

  • Ich brauche nicht zu warten.
  • Du brauchst das nicht zu machen.

In standard German, zu is normally included.

Is brauchen nicht zu the same as müssen nicht?

Usually, yes. Both can mean do not have to.

So these are very close:

  • Ich brauche meiner Schwägerin nicht noch einmal zu schreiben.
  • Ich muss meiner Schwägerin nicht noch einmal schreiben.

A useful warning for English speakers:

  • German ich muss nicht means I do not have to
  • English I must not means I am not allowed to

So German nicht müssen is often softer than English must not.

Why is it meiner Schwägerin and not meine Schwägerin?

Because schreiben usually takes the person receiving the message in the dative:

  • jemandem schreiben = to write to someone

So:

  • meine Schwägerin = nominative or accusative
  • meiner Schwägerin = dative

In this sentence, the sister-in-law is the recipient of the writing, so dative is required:

  • meiner Schwägerin
Could you also say an meine Schwägerin schreiben?

Yes, you can.

German commonly allows both:

  • jemandem schreiben
  • an jemanden schreiben

The dative version, jemandem schreiben, is very common and natural when you mean write to someone in general.

The version with an can sound a little more like the message is directed or addressed to that person:

  • Ich schreibe meiner Schwägerin.
  • Ich schreibe an meine Schwägerin.

In this sentence, meiner Schwägerin schreiben is perfectly normal.

What exactly does nicht noch einmal mean?

Noch einmal means:

  • once again
  • one more time
  • again

So:

  • nicht noch einmal zu schreiben = not to write again / not to write one more time

The position of nicht shows that the idea of writing again is being negated.

A useful contrast:

  • nicht noch einmal = not again
  • noch nicht einmal = not even yet / not even once

Those are very different.

Also, in everyday speech, noch einmal is often shortened to nochmal.

Why is zu schreiben at the end of the clause?

Because German puts the infinitive at the end in constructions like brauchen + zu + infinitive.

So the clause is built like this:

  • brauche = conjugated verb
  • zu schreiben = infinitive phrase at the end

This is normal German word order:

  • Ich brauche das nicht zu machen.
  • Wir brauchen nicht zu warten.

The finite verb comes early, and the infinitive goes to the end.

Why is there a comma before weil?

Because weil introduces a subordinate clause, and in German that clause must be separated by a comma.

So:

  • main clause: Im September brauche ich meiner Schwägerin nicht noch einmal zu schreiben
  • subordinate clause: weil sie immer sofort antwortet

German punctuation requires this comma.

Why is antwortet at the end after weil?

Because weil is a subordinating conjunction, and in subordinate clauses the conjugated verb normally goes to the end.

So:

  • weil sie immer sofort antwortet

This is standard German subordinate-clause word order.

Compare:

  • main clause: Sie antwortet immer sofort.
  • subordinate clause: ..., weil sie immer sofort antwortet.
What does sie refer to here?

Here sie refers to meiner Schwägerin, so it means she.

German sie can mean several things:

  • she
  • they
  • you (formal, as Sie)

But in this sentence, the context makes it clear that it means she, because the nearest logical antecedent is Schwägerin, which is feminine singular.

Why is there no object after antwortet or after schreiben?

Because German often leaves out objects when they are already understood from context.

For example:

  • schreiben does not always need a direct object like einen Brief or eine Nachricht
  • antworten does not always need an explicit object either

Here the idea is clear:

  • I do not need to write to my sister-in-law again
  • because she always replies immediately

So German does not need to spell out:

  • auf meine Nachricht
  • mir
  • eine Antwort

All of that is understood from the situation.