Breakdown of Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler, n'est-ce pas ?
Questions & Answers about Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler, n'est-ce pas ?
Why does French say tu as froid instead of something like tu es froid?
Because French uses avoir with many physical sensations:
- avoir froid = to be cold / to feel cold
- avoir chaud = to be hot
- avoir faim = to be hungry
- avoir soif = to be thirsty
So tu as froid literally looks like you have cold, but it means you are cold or you feel cold.
Tu es froid usually means you are cold in the sense of emotionally cold, or that your body/object is cold as a characteristic, not simply that you feel chilly.
Why is it si tu as froid and not quand tu as froid?
Si means if, so si tu as froid means if you are cold.
That suggests a condition: if this happens, then that happens.
- Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler. = If you are cold, you start to shiver.
- Quand tu as froid, tu commences à trembler. = When you are cold, you start to shiver.
In many contexts, both can make sense, but the nuance is slightly different:
- si = condition
- quand = when/whenever, something more expected or habitual
Why are both verbs in the present tense: si tu as... tu commences...?
French often uses the present + present pattern for general truths, habits, or things that usually happen.
So:
- Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler.
means something like:
- If you’re cold, you start shivering
- When you get cold, you start shivering
This is not the same as English If you are cold, you will start shivering, even though the meaning can be similar. French does not normally use the future after si in this kind of sentence.
A useful rule:
- after si meaning if, French does not use the future tense in this structure
So Si tu auras froid... would be wrong here.
Why is tu repeated? Why not just say Si tu as froid, commences à trembler?
Because the second clause needs its own subject.
French usually states the subject clearly with each conjugated verb:
- Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler.
The first tu belongs to as. The second tu belongs to commences.
If you said Si tu as froid, commences à trembler, that would sound like a command:
- If you’re cold, start shivering.
So the repeated tu is necessary because this sentence is making a statement, not giving an order.
What does commencer à mean here?
Why is there an à after commences?
Because commencer is followed by à before another verb in the infinitive.
Pattern:
- commencer à + infinitive
So:
- tu commences à trembler
This is just how the verb is built in this meaning.
Compare:
- apprendre à faire quelque chose = to learn to do something
- aider à faire quelque chose = to help to do something
You usually have to learn which preposition goes with each verb.
What exactly does trembler mean? Is it the same as frissonner?
Trembler means to tremble, shake, or shiver.
In this sentence, it means to shiver because of cold.
Frissonner can also mean to shiver, often with a slight nuance of a chill or shudder. In many situations, the two are close, but trembler is the more general word for shaking.
Examples:
So here, trembler is perfectly natural.
What is n'est-ce pas ? doing at the end of the sentence?
N'est-ce pas ? is a tag question, like English:
- ..., isn’t it?
- ..., right?
- ..., don’t you?
- ..., aren’t you?
In this sentence it is asking for confirmation:
- Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler, n'est-ce pas ?
- If you’re cold, you start shivering, right?
It’s a fixed expression and does not change to match the subject the way English tags do. English would say don’t you? here, but French can simply use n’est-ce pas ?
Why is it n'est-ce pas and not something that matches tu, like n'as-tu pas?
Because n'est-ce pas ? is a fixed tag expression meaning something like isn’t that so?
It does not work like English tag questions, where you change the auxiliary depending on the sentence:
- You’re cold, aren’t you?
- You started, didn’t you?
French often avoids that kind of changing tag and uses the more general n’est-ce pas ?
You may also hear more informal tags such as:
- hein ?
- non ?
- pas vrai ?
But n’est-ce pas ? is standard and clear.
Why are there hyphens in n'est-ce?
Why is it tu and not vous?
Tu is the singular informal you.
Vous is used for:
- one person in a formal situation
- more than one person
So tu suggests the speaker is talking to:
- a friend
- a child
- a family member
- someone they know well
If you wanted the formal or plural version, you could say:
- Si vous avez froid, vous commencez à trembler, n'est-ce pas ?
Could I say Si tu es froid if I’m talking about body temperature?
Is the comma necessary before n'est-ce pas ?
The comma is very common because n’est-ce pas ? is added like a short extra tag at the end:
- ..., n’est-ce pas ?
It helps show a pause, just like in English:
- ..., right?
- ..., isn’t it?
In informal writing, punctuation can vary, but using the comma is standard and a good habit.
Can tu commences à trembler also mean you are beginning to tremble?
Yes. The form can be understood as:
- you start to tremble
- you begin to tremble
- you are starting to tremble
The exact English translation depends on context. In French, the present tense often covers ideas that English may express with either the simple present or the present progressive.
So tu commences à trembler is flexible, but in this sentence it most naturally means a general reaction:
- you start shivering
How would this sentence sound more natural in everyday spoken French?
The given sentence is correct, but in everyday speech people might say simpler or more idiomatic things, for example:
- Si tu as froid, tu te mets à trembler, non ?
- Quand tu as froid, tu trembles, non ?
- Quand t’as froid, tu commences à trembler, non ?
A few notes:
- te mettre à + infinitive also means to start doing something
- non ? is a common casual tag instead of n’est-ce pas ?
- t’as is the spoken contraction of tu as
So the original sentence is perfectly correct, but n’est-ce pas ? can sound a bit more formal or deliberate than everyday conversation.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning FrenchMaster French — from Si tu as froid, tu commences à trembler, n'est-ce pas to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions