Breakdown of U poruci je objašnjeno da će domaća zadaća biti kratka, ali da mora biti uredna.
Questions & Answers about U poruci je objašnjeno da će domaća zadaća biti kratka, ali da mora biti uredna.
Why is it u poruci and not u poruka?
Because u meaning in takes the locative case when it expresses location.
- Base form: poruka = message
- Locative singular: poruci
- So u poruci = in the message
This is a very common pattern in Croatian:
- u školi = in school
- u knjizi = in the book
- u poruci = in the message
If u meant movement into something, it would usually take the accusative instead.
Why is it je objašnjeno? Why not je objašnjena to match poruka?
Because objašnjeno does not describe poruka.
Here, u poruci is just telling you where something was explained. The core structure is:
- je objašnjeno = it was explained
This is an impersonal passive-like construction. Croatian often uses the neuter singular form in this kind of sentence when the real content comes afterward in a da-clause.
So the logic is roughly:
- U poruci je objašnjeno...
- In the message, it was explained...
The thing being explained is the whole clause that follows:
- da će domaća zadaća biti kratka...
So objašnjeno is neuter singular because it works like English it was explained, not because it agrees with poruka.
What does da do in this sentence?
Here da introduces a content clause, similar to English that.
So:
- je objašnjeno da... = it was explained that...
In this sentence, da introduces what was explained:
- da će domaća zadaća biti kratka
- that the homework will/would be short
This use of da is extremely common in Croatian after verbs of saying, knowing, explaining, thinking, etc.
For example:
- Znam da dolazi. = I know that he/she is coming.
- Rekla je da nema vremena. = She said that she doesn’t have time.
- Objasnili su da je važno. = They explained that it is important.
Why is da repeated after ali?
Because there are two coordinated clauses, and both depend on je objašnjeno.
So the structure is:
Repeating da makes the structure clearer and more balanced. It shows that both ideas are part of what was explained.
In English, we often do the same:
- It was explained that the homework would be short, but that it had to be neat.
Could Croatian sometimes omit the second da? In some contexts, yes, but here repeating it is very natural and standard.
Why do we get će ... biti in da će domaća zadaća biti kratka?
That is the future tense.
Croatian future I is normally formed with:
- a form of htjeti as an auxiliary: ću, ćeš, će, ćemo, ćete, će
- plus the infinitive
Here:
- će biti = will be
So:
- domaća zadaća će biti kratka = the homework will be short
After da, the auxiliary usually comes right after it:
- da će domaća zadaća biti kratka
That placement is normal because će is a clitic-like auxiliary and tends to appear near the beginning of the clause.
Why is it mora biti uredna and not će morati biti uredna?
Because mora biti expresses a requirement more directly: it must be neat.
- mora biti = must be / has to be
- će morati biti = will have to be
In this sentence, the speaker is presenting a rule or requirement about the homework, not mainly focusing on the future moment of obligation. So mora biti uredna sounds more natural.
Compare:
- Zadaća će biti kratka. = The homework will be short.
- Zadaća mora biti uredna. = The homework must be neat.
You could say da će morati biti uredna, but that would shift the nuance more toward it will have to be neat, which is a bit heavier and less simple.
Why are domaća, kratka, and uredna all feminine?
Because they all relate to zadaća, which is a feminine singular noun.
Croatian adjectives must agree with the noun in:
So:
- zadaća = feminine singular
- domaća zadaća = feminine singular adjective + feminine singular noun
- kratka = feminine singular
- uredna = feminine singular
That is why you see the -a ending on all of them.
If the noun were masculine, the forms would change:
- kratak
- uredan
If it were neuter:
- kratko
- uredno
Why is domaća zadaća in the nominative?
Because it is the subject of the clause:
In that subordinate clause, the homework is the thing that will be short, so it stays in the nominative.
The conjunction da does not automatically force a different case. Case depends on the noun’s role in the clause.
Here:
- domaća zadaća = subject
- therefore nominative
What exactly is domaća zadaća? Is it always the usual way to say homework?
Domaća zadaća is a standard Croatian expression for homework.
Literally:
- domaća = home, domestic
- zadaća = task / assignment
So the phrase literally means something like home assignment, but in normal usage it simply means homework.
You may also hear just:
- zadaća
when the context already makes it clear that it is homework.
Does uredna mean neat/tidy here?
Yes. In this context, uredna means something like:
- neat
- tidy
- well-presented
When talking about schoolwork, uredna zadaća usually means the homework should be clean, organized, and carefully written.
So it is not about being short only; it also has to be presented properly.
Can the word order be changed?
Yes, Croatian word order is flexible, but not completely free.
The sentence as given is natural and neutral:
You could rearrange some parts for emphasis, but you must be careful with clitics like je and će, which have preferred positions.
For example, je in je objašnjeno and će in da će... are not placed randomly.
So while Croatian allows more flexibility than English, the given order is a very good standard model for learners.
Could this sentence be expressed in a more active way?
Yes. Croatian often allows both an impersonal/passive-like style and a more active style.
For example:
That means roughly:
- In the message, they explained that the homework would be short, but that it had to be neat.
The original version with je objašnjeno is more impersonal and often sounds more formal or neutral. It avoids naming who did the explaining.
So:
- je objašnjeno = impersonal, neutral
- su objasnili = active, with an implied they
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from U poruci je objašnjeno da će domaća zadaća biti kratka, ali da mora biti uredna to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions