Breakdown of Volgens die dokument is hierdie antwoord duidelik.
Questions & Answers about Volgens die dokument is hierdie antwoord duidelik.
Why is is placed before hierdie antwoord? I would expect something like Volgens die dokument hierdie antwoord is duidelik.
This is a very common Afrikaans word-order question.
Afrikaans is a verb-second (V2) language in main clauses. That means the finite verb usually comes in the second position of the sentence.
In this sentence:
Volgens die dokument | is | hierdie antwoord duidelik
- Volgens die dokument is the first element.
- So the verb is must come next.
- Then the subject hierdie antwoord follows.
If you start with the subject instead, you get:
Hierdie antwoord is volgens die dokument duidelik.
That is also grammatical, but the emphasis is slightly different.
So the sentence structure is normal Afrikaans:
- first element: Volgens die dokument
- second position: is
- then the rest of the sentence
What does volgens mean, and how is it used?
Volgens usually means according to.
So:
- Volgens die dokument = According to the document
It is used to introduce a source of information, opinion, or authority.
Examples:
- Volgens die onderwyser is dit reg.
= According to the teacher, this is correct. - Volgens die nuus gaan dit reën.
= According to the news, it is going to rain.
A useful thing to notice is that volgens is followed directly by a noun phrase:
- volgens die dokument
- volgens hom
- volgens my
Why do we use die in die dokument?
Die is the normal Afrikaans definite article, meaning the.
So:
- die dokument = the document
Afrikaans does not distinguish between the for masculine, feminine, or neuter nouns. It is simply die for all of them.
Examples:
- die boek = the book
- die tafel = the table
- die man = the man
So in this sentence, die dokument just means the document.
What is the difference between die and hierdie in this sentence?
They are doing different jobs:
- die dokument = the document
- hierdie antwoord = this answer
So:
- die = the
- hierdie = this
Hierdie is a demonstrative, used to point something out as being near or relevant in context.
Compare:
- hierdie antwoord = this answer
- daardie antwoord = that answer
- die antwoord = the answer
For an English speaker, it helps to think:
- die = definite article
- hierdie / daardie = demonstratives
Why is it hierdie antwoord and not some changed form of antwoord?
Because antwoord is just the noun answer, and Afrikaans nouns usually do not change form for this kind of use.
In English, we also say:
- this answer
- not this answered or anything similar
Afrikaans works the same way here:
- hierdie antwoord = this answer
Also, Afrikaans nouns do not change for grammatical gender, and they generally do not change form after demonstratives.
Why is duidelik not written as duidelike?
This is an excellent question because Afrikaans adjectives behave differently depending on where they appear.
In your sentence, duidelik comes after the verb is:
- Hierdie antwoord is duidelik.
Here it is a predicative adjective, and in that position Afrikaans normally uses the basic form:
- duidelik = clear
But when the adjective comes before a noun, it often takes -e:
- 'n duidelike antwoord = a clear answer
So compare:
- Die antwoord is duidelik.
predicative adjective - Dit is 'n duidelike antwoord.
attributive adjective
That is why the sentence uses duidelik, not duidelike.
Is hierdie antwoord the subject of the sentence?
Yes. The subject is hierdie antwoord.
Even though it comes after the verb, it is still the subject.
The sentence is basically:
- Volgens die dokument = according to the document
- is = is
- hierdie antwoord = this answer
- duidelik = clear
So the core statement is:
Hierdie antwoord is duidelik.
= This answer is clear.
The phrase Volgens die dokument is extra information placed at the front.
Can the sentence also be written as Hierdie antwoord is volgens die dokument duidelik?
Yes, that is possible.
Both are grammatical:
- Volgens die dokument is hierdie antwoord duidelik.
- Hierdie antwoord is volgens die dokument duidelik.
The difference is mainly one of focus or emphasis.
- Starting with Volgens die dokument puts emphasis on the source.
- Starting with Hierdie antwoord puts emphasis on the answer itself.
Afrikaans often moves elements to the front for emphasis, but the finite verb still stays in second position in a main clause.
Is there anything special about the verb is here?
Yes. Is is the present-tense form of wees (to be), and here it works as a linking verb.
It links:
- the subject: hierdie antwoord
- to the description: duidelik
So the structure is like:
- This answer
- is
- clear
- is
This is very similar to English.
Also note that Afrikaans does not usually use do-support the way English does. So simple present linking sentences are very straightforward:
Could I replace hierdie with die or daardie?
Yes, but the meaning changes slightly.
Compare:
- hierdie antwoord = this answer
- daardie antwoord = that answer
- die antwoord = the answer
- Volgens die dokument is die antwoord duidelik.
- Volgens die dokument is daardie antwoord duidelik.
Each version is grammatical, but the demonstrative choice changes how specifically you point to the answer.
Use:
- hierdie when something is close, current, or immediately relevant
- daardie when it is more distant
- die when you just mean the
Do I need a comma after Volgens die dokument?
How would a word-for-word breakdown of the sentence look?
Is the sentence formal, neutral, or casual?
It sounds neutral to slightly formal.
- Volgens die dokument = a fairly formal way to refer to a source
- duidelik = standard, neutral vocabulary
It would fit well in:
- schoolwork
- reports
- official communication
- careful spoken Afrikaans
It is not overly stiff, but it is more formal than something very conversational.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning AfrikaansMaster Afrikaans — from Volgens die dokument is hierdie antwoord duidelik to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions