Word
Nous voulions atterrir à Paris, mais il y avait une tempête.
Meaning
We wanted to land in Paris, but there was a storm.
Part of speech
sentence
Pronunciation
Course
Breakdown of Nous voulions atterrir à Paris, mais il y avait une tempête.
une
a / an (feminine)
mais
but
nous
we / us (object pronoun)
il y a
there is / there are
Questions & Answers about Nous voulions atterrir à Paris, mais il y avait une tempête.
Why use the imparfait voulions instead of the passé composé avons voulu here?
In the imparfait, vouloir simply describes an ongoing state of mind or intention in the past ("we wanted to"). If you used the passé composé (nous avons voulu), it would imply a specific, completed attempt or a sudden decision, which often translates to "we tried to" or "we decided to." Here, their ongoing intention to land was thwarted by the weather.
Based on the tenses used, did the plane actually land in Paris?
Probably not. Using the imparfait voulions indicates that the desire existed, but it crucially doesn't confirm that the action was ever completed. Combined with the obstacle of the storm (mais il y avait une tempête), the strong implication is that their intention was interrupted and they had to land elsewhere.
Why is il y avait also in the imparfait? Could we say il y a eu?
Do we never need a preposition like à or de between voulions and atterrir?