Breakdown of As sy vroeër geskop het, sou die telling anders gewees het.
die
the
sy
she
wees
to be
vroeër
earlier
as
if, when
sou
would
anders
different
het
has, have (auxiliary of the past tense)
skop
to kick
telling
score
Questions & Answers about As sy vroeër geskop het, sou die telling anders gewees het.
Why does Afrikaans just say geskop het in the first half instead of a special form for "had kicked"?
In English, you use the past perfect ("had kicked") to show that an "if" clause is about an unreal past. In Afrikaans, the ordinary past tense (geskop het) is normally enough in the as-clause, because sou ... gewees het in the second half already makes it clear that the whole sentence is about something that did not happen in the past. (You may occasionally hear sou geskop het in the as-clause too, especially in spoken Afrikaans, though standard writing prefers plain geskop het.)
Why is it gewees het at the end instead of was?
On its own, the past tense of is is simply was (Die telling was anders — The score was different). However, when you combine it with a modal verb like sou (would), kon (could), or moes (should / had to) to talk about the past, was is not used. Instead, Afrikaans uses the past participle gewees followed by het, so sou ... gewees het means "would have been". Notice the word order at the very end: the past participle (gewees) comes before het, the opposite of English "have been".
Why does sou come before die telling right after the comma?
This is the Afrikaans verb-second (V2) word order in action. First, the subordinating conjunction as sends the verbs geskop het to the end of the first clause. Then, that entire as-clause counts as the first element of the full sentence, so the main verb of the second clause (sou) comes immediately next, right after the comma and before its subject (die telling).
Can I leave out as at the beginning, the way English says "Had she kicked earlier..."?
Yes. Just as English can replace "If she had..." with "Had she...", Afrikaans can drop as and start the sentence directly with Het: Het sy vroeër geskop, sou die telling anders gewees het. When het moves to the front like this, the past participle geskop stays at the end of the first clause on its own.
Why is vroeër spelled with two dots over the second e, and where did the g from vroeg go?
Vroeër (earlier) is the comparative form of vroeg (early). When -er is added to vroeg, the g drops out between the vowels. In Afrikaans, the two dots (deelteken) on the second e show that it starts a new syllable, so you pronounce it vroe-er rather than reading ee as a single long vowel.
Learn As sy vroeër geskop het, sou die telling anders gewees het and more in Afrikaans
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free