Eles não são os últimos dinossauros a evoluir, mas sim os primeiros.

Questions & Answers about Eles não são os últimos dinossauros a evoluir, mas sim os primeiros.

Why do we use mas sim here instead of just mas?
We use mas sim (but rather / but instead) to strongly correct a previous negative statement. Because the first half explicitly denies something (não são os últimos), adding sim after mas directly replaces the false information with the true information, making the contrast much stronger.
Why is there an a before evoluir? Couldn't we just use the infinitive directly?
In Portuguese, when an infinitive describes a noun—especially after adjectives like últimos (last), primeiros (first), or únicos (only)—you must connect them with the preposition a. You cannot just say dinossauros evoluir. Alternatively, you could use a relative clause like que evoluíram (that evolved).
Does os primeiros mean 'the first ones' here?
Exactly. You do not need to repeat the noun dinossauros because the definite article os paired with the ordinal number primeiros acts as a pronoun. It matches the masculine plural gender of the dinosaurs being discussed, completely replacing the need to say the full phrase again.
Would the sentence still be correct if I left out the sim?
Yes, saying ...mas os primeiros is grammatically correct. However, in a 'not X, but Y' structure, adding sim is highly natural and preferred in Portuguese. It serves as a spotlight to emphasize that the second part is the actual truth correcting the previous negative statement.

Learn Eles não são os últimos dinossauros a evoluir, mas sim os primeiros and more in Portuguese

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
  • ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free