Breakdown of Se o molho ficar azedo, minha avó tira as sementes do tomate e começa de novo.
Questions & Answers about Se o molho ficar azedo, minha avó tira as sementes do tomate e começa de novo.
Why is it ficar after se? Is that the infinitive?
Here, ficar is most naturally understood as the future subjunctive.
In Portuguese, after se meaning if, when you are talking about a possible future situation, Portuguese often uses the future subjunctive:
- Se eu for... = If I go...
- Se ele tiver... = If he has...
- Se o molho ficar azedo... = If the sauce turns sour...
With many -ar verbs, the future subjunctive form looks exactly like the infinitive, so ficar can look confusing. But in this sentence, it is functioning as future subjunctive, not as a plain infinitive.
Why does Portuguese use ficar azedo instead of something like ser azedo or estar azedo?
Why is it azedo and not azeda?
Why is the main part of the sentence in the present tense: minha avó tira... e começa...?
The present tense here expresses a habitual action or a general reaction.
So the sentence means something like:
- Whenever the sauce turns sour, my grandmother removes the tomato seeds and starts again.
Portuguese often uses the present indicative for things someone regularly does:
It is not necessarily about one single event happening right now; it can describe what usually happens.
What exactly does tira mean here?
Tira comes from tirar, which often means:
- to take out
- to remove
- to pull out
In this sentence, minha avó tira as sementes do tomate means she removes the seeds from the tomato.
It is a very common everyday verb in Brazilian Portuguese.
Why is it do tomate?
Why is it as sementes with the article as?
Portuguese uses definite articles more often than English does.
So as sementes literally means the seeds. In English, you might sometimes just say remove seeds, but Portuguese usually prefers the article here.
This sounds natural in Portuguese:
- tirar as sementes do tomate
Without the article, it would sound less standard in this context.
Why is there no article before minha avó? Could it also be a minha avó?
Yes, both are possible in Brazilian Portuguese:
- minha avó
- a minha avó
In Brazil, possessives can appear with or without the definite article, depending on region, style, and level of formality.
So:
- minha avó tira...
- a minha avó tira...
Both can sound natural. The version without the article is very common.
What does começa de novo mean exactly? Is it the same as recomeça?
Começa de novo means starts again.
It is very close in meaning to recomeça:
- começa de novo = starts again
- recomeça = restarts / starts again
In everyday Brazilian Portuguese, começar de novo is very common and sounds natural and conversational.
In this sentence, it suggests that she abandons the spoiled attempt and begins the process again.
Why is the sentence not Se o molho está azedo?
Because Portuguese treats this as a future or possible condition, not a simple statement of current fact.
Compare:
- Se o molho ficar azedo... = If the sauce turns sour / if the sauce ends up sour
- Se o molho está azedo... = If the sauce is sour...
The second one is much less natural for this kind of conditional idea. After se, Portuguese usually prefers the future subjunctive when talking about something that may happen.
Is molho always sauce, or can it mean other things?
Usually, molho means sauce in cooking contexts.
Examples:
- molho de tomate = tomato sauce
- molho branco = white sauce
- molho pesto = pesto sauce
Depending on context, molho can also refer more broadly to a liquid mixture or dressing, but sauce is the main meaning here.
How would this sentence sound more natural in everyday English structure if translated literally?
A more word-for-word breakdown would be:
- Se = if
- o molho = the sauce
- ficar azedo = becomes sour / turns sour
- minha avó = my grandmother
- tira = removes / takes out
- as sementes = the seeds
- do tomate = from the tomato
- e começa de novo = and starts again
So the literal structure is roughly:
If the sauce turns sour, my grandmother removes the tomato seeds and starts again.
That is already quite close to natural English, but it is useful to notice that ficar carries the idea of becoming, not just being.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from Se o molho ficar azedo, minha avó tira as sementes do tomate e começa de novo to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions