Breakdown of Minha filha tirou a casca do abacaxi, mas deixou a casca do mamão na mesa.
Questions & Answers about Minha filha tirou a casca do abacaxi, mas deixou a casca do mamão na mesa.
Why is it minha filha and not meu filha?
Because possessive adjectives agree with the noun that follows.
Compare:
- meu filho = my son
- minha filha = my daughter
It does not agree with the speaker’s gender. A man and a woman would both say minha filha.
Why is there no article before minha filha?
In Brazilian Portuguese, it is very common to use a possessive directly with a family noun:
- minha filha
- meu pai
- nossa mãe
You can also hear a minha filha in some varieties or for emphasis, but minha filha sounds very natural in Brazil.
So both can exist, but the version without the article is extremely common.
What does tirou mean here?
Tirou is the preterite form of tirar, meaning something like:
- removed
- took off
- took away
Here, tirou a casca do abacaxi means she removed the pineapple peel.
The preterite is used because this is a completed action in the past.
- tirar = to remove / take off
- tirou = removed / took off
Why is it a casca?
Why do we say do abacaxi and do mamão?
Why is it do abacaxi if abacaxi ends in -i? Is it masculine?
Why is a casca repeated instead of just saying tirou a casca do abacaxi, mas deixou do mamão na mesa?
Because deixou do mamão would be incomplete and unnatural here.
Portuguese normally repeats the noun for clarity:
- tirou a casca do abacaxi, mas deixou a casca do mamão na mesa
You could shorten it in some contexts:
- ...mas deixou a do mamão na mesa
That works because a stands in for a casca. But the full version is clearer and more neutral.
What exactly does deixou mean here?
Here, deixou means left in the sense of left something somewhere.
- deixou a casca do mamão na mesa = left the papaya peel on the table
It is the preterite of deixar, so again it describes a completed past action.
Be careful: deixar can have several meanings depending on context, such as:
- to leave
- to let
- to allow
In this sentence, it clearly means left.
Why is it na mesa?
Does na mesa go with mamão or with deixou?
Could tirou a casca do abacaxi also be expressed another way in Portuguese?
Yes. A very natural alternative would be:
- descascou o abacaxi
That literally means peeled the pineapple.
So these are close in meaning:
- tirou a casca do abacaxi
- descascou o abacaxi
The sentence you were given is slightly more explicit because it directly mentions a casca.
Why is the comma used before mas?
How is mamão pronounced, especially the -ão ending?
The ending -ão is a very common nasal ending in Portuguese.
So mamão is not pronounced like an English ow sound. The final part is nasal, roughly like ma-MOWN with the last syllable nasalized.
A few helpful notes:
- stress is on the last syllable: ma-MÃO
- the -ão sound appears in many words:
- pão
- mão
- não
This ending often takes practice for English speakers because English does not use nasal vowels in the same way.
Is the tense in both verbs the same?
Yes. Both tirou and deixou are in the preterite.
- tirou = removed
- deixou = left
The preterite is used because the sentence tells a sequence of completed actions in the past.
If the sentence were describing habitual or ongoing background action, Portuguese might use a different past tense, but here the preterite is the natural choice.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning PortugueseMaster Portuguese — from Minha filha tirou a casca do abacaxi, mas deixou a casca do mamão na mesa to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions