Breakdown of Mater dicit librum in tablino positum esse et flores ante lararium a filia positos esse.
Questions & Answers about Mater dicit librum in tablino positum esse et flores ante lararium a filia positos esse.
Why is there no Latin word meaning that after dicit?
Because Latin often uses indirect statement instead of a that-clause.
After a verb like dicit (says), Latin commonly puts:
- the subject of the reported statement in the accusative
- the verb of the reported statement in the infinitive
So:
Mater dicit librum positum esse
literally = Mother says the book to have been placed
natural English = Mother says that the book has been placed
This is one of the most important Latin constructions to learn.
Why is librum accusative, even though the book is the thing being placed?
In an indirect statement, the subject of the infinitive goes into the accusative.
So in:
librum in tablino positum esse
the word librum is not the direct object of positum esse. It is actually the subject of that infinitive phrase, but Latin puts that subject in the accusative because the whole clause depends on dicit.
You can compare:
- direct statement: liber in tablino positus est = the book has been placed in the study
- indirect statement: mater dicit librum in tablino positum esse = mother says that the book has been placed in the study
Notice how liber becomes librum.
What exactly is positum esse?
Positum esse is the perfect passive infinitive of pono, ponere, posui, positum (to place, put).
It is made from:
- the perfect passive participle: positum
- plus esse
So:
- positum esse = to have been placed
- in smoother English here: has been placed or was placed
The same pattern appears again in:
- positos esse = to have been placed for a plural masculine noun
Why do we get positum with librum but positos with flores?
Because the participle must agree with the noun it goes with in:
- gender
- number
- case
So:
librum = masculine singular accusative
→ positumflores = masculine plural accusative
→ positos
Even though positum/positos is part of the verb phrase positum esse / positos esse, it is still a participle and therefore agrees like an adjective.
Why is it in tablino but ante lararium?
Because the two prepositions work differently.
in with the ablative usually means in / on a place
so in tablino = in the studyante takes the accusative
so ante lararium = in front of the household shrine
A very common thing for learners to remember is:
- in + ablative = in somewhere
- in + accusative = into somewhere
Here it is in tablino, so it means location, not motion.
Why is a filia ablative?
Because with a passive verb, the personal agent is often expressed by a/ab + ablative.
So:
- a filia = by the daughter
This tells you who did the action of placing the flowers.
A useful contrast:
- a filia = by the daughter after a passive verb
- if Latin were simply saying the daughter placed the flowers, then filia would be nominative
Why is it a filia and not ab filia?
Both a and ab mean the same thing here.
Before a consonant, Latin often uses a, though ab can also appear.
Before a vowel, ab is more usual.
Since filia begins with f, a filia is perfectly normal.
Why is esse repeated after both parts of the sentence?
Because there are really two parallel indirect statements joined by et:
- librum in tablino positum esse
- flores ante lararium a filia positos esse
Each one needs its own infinitive, so esse is repeated.
This makes the structure very clear:
- Mother says that the book has been placed...
- and that the flowers have been placed...
Why is flores masculine? I might have expected positas.
Because flos, floris (flower) is a masculine noun in Latin.
Its plural accusative is flores, so the participle must also be masculine plural accusative:
- flores ... positos esse
If the noun were feminine plural accusative, then positas would be right, but not here.
Is the word order unusual? Could the sentence be arranged differently?
Yes, Latin word order is much freer than English word order.
This sentence separates nouns from their participles:
- librum ... positum esse
- flores ... positos esse
and places the location phrases in between:
- in tablino
- ante lararium
That is normal Latin style. The endings tell you which words belong together.
So a learner should look for:
- librum ↔ positum
- flores ↔ positos
rather than expecting the words to stay next to each other the way they usually would in English.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Mater dicit librum in tablino positum esse et flores ante lararium a filia positos esse to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions