Breakdown of Mater dicit se non crudelem, sed clementem esse velle, etiam cum pueri culpam fateri timent.
Questions & Answers about Mater dicit se non crudelem, sed clementem esse velle, etiam cum pueri culpam fateri timent.
Why is se used here instead of eam?
Because se is the reflexive pronoun. It refers back to the subject of the main verb, which is Mater.
- Mater dicit se ... velle = The mother says that she wants...
- Here, she means the mother herself, so Latin uses se.
If Latin used eam, that would normally suggest some other woman/girl, not the mother.
Why do we get dicit se ... velle instead of something like dicit quod vult?
After verbs of saying, thinking, knowing, and perceiving, Latin very often uses an indirect statement construction:
- subject in the accusative
- verb in the infinitive
So:
- Mater dicit se ... velle = Mother says that she wants...
This is a standard Latin pattern. English usually uses that, but Latin often uses the accusative-and-infinitive construction instead.
Why are both velle and esse infinitives?
They are doing two different jobs.
- velle is infinitive because it is part of the indirect statement after dicit.
- esse is infinitive because velle normally takes an infinitive complement: to want to be.
So the structure is:
- dicit = says
- se velle = that she wants
- esse clementem = to be merciful
Put together:
- Mater dicit se ... esse velle = Mother says that she wants to be...
Why are crudelem and clementem accusative, not nominative?
Because they agree with se, and se is accusative.
In an indirect statement, the subject of the infinitive is put in the accusative. Any predicate adjective describing that subject also goes into the accusative.
So:
- se crudelem esse = that she is cruel
- se clementem esse velle = that she wants to be merciful
If this were direct speech, the adjectives would be nominative:
- volo crudelis / clemens esse would be incorrect as stated, because predicate adjectives with esse should match the subject in nominative:
- volo crudelis? No.
- Correct direct idea: volo clemens esse = I want to be merciful
Since the indirect statement uses se, the adjectives become crudelem and clementem.
Why is it non crudelem, sed clementem?
This is a very common Latin contrast pattern:
- non ... sed ... = not ... but ...
So:
- non crudelem, sed clementem = not cruel, but merciful
Latin places non before the thing being denied, and sed introduces the correction or contrast.
Does se non crudelem, sed clementem esse velle literally mean she wants herself to be...?
In a very literal grammatical sense, yes: se is the subject of the infinitive, so it is like herself.
But in natural English, we usually just say:
- she wants to be not cruel, but merciful or better
- she wants to be merciful rather than cruel
So although se is explicitly present in Latin, it usually does not need to be translated as herself in normal English.
Why is cum followed by timent in the indicative, not the subjunctive?
Here cum means when, in a straightforward temporal sense:
- etiam cum pueri ... timent = even when the boys are afraid...
In that use, cum commonly takes the indicative.
If cum introduced a more circumstantial or concessive clause, especially in more literary Latin, you might expect the subjunctive. But here the sense is simply temporal:
- even when the boys are afraid
So timent is perfectly natural.
What does etiam cum mean here?
Etiam cum means even when.
- cum = when
- etiam adds the sense of even
So the whole phrase adds emphasis:
- even when the boys are afraid to admit their fault
It shows that the mother wants to be merciful not only in easy situations, but also in difficult ones.
Why is pueri nominative?
Because pueri is the subject of timent.
In the clause:
- cum pueri culpam fateri timent
the boys are the ones doing the fearing. So:
- pueri = the boys
- timent = are afraid
That is why pueri is nominative.
What is culpam fateri?
It means to admit/confess a fault or to admit guilt.
- culpam = fault, blame, guilt
- fateri = to admit, confess
So:
- culpam fateri timent = they are afraid to admit their fault or = they are afraid to confess their guilt
Why is fateri active in meaning even though it looks passive?
Because fateri comes from fateor, which is a deponent verb.
A deponent verb:
- has passive forms
- but an active meaning
So:
- fateor = I confess / admit
- fateri = to confess / to admit
Even though the form looks passive, the meaning is active.
Why is the word order so different from English?
Latin word order is much more flexible than English word order. The endings tell you what each word is doing, so Latin can move words around for emphasis.
Here the order highlights the contrast:
- se non crudelem, sed clementem puts not cruel, but merciful in a prominent position
Then the infinitives come after:
- esse velle = to want to be
A more English-like order would be something like:
- Mater dicit se velle non crudelem, sed clementem esse
But the given word order is perfectly good Latin and gives strong emphasis to the contrast between crudelem and clementem.
What would this look like in direct speech instead of indirect speech?
The indirect statement is:
- Mater dicit se non crudelem, sed clementem esse velle.
In direct speech, the mother would say something like:
- Non crudelem, sed clementem esse volo. = I want to be not cruel, but merciful.
Notice the changes:
- se becomes the implied I
- velle becomes volo
- crudelem and clementem would normally become nominative if expressed with a nominative subject, but with esse volo and an understood ego, Latin often leaves the adjectives to be understood through the construction; many learners are safest thinking of the direct version mainly as:
- volo clemens esse
- I want to be merciful
The key point is that the indirect statement turns the mother’s I want into she says that she wants.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Mater dicit se non crudelem, sed clementem esse velle, etiam cum pueri culpam fateri timent to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions