Breakdown of kyou ha tamago no tokubai desita ga, watasi ga itta toki ni ha mou urikire desita.
Questions & Answers about kyou ha tamago no tokubai desita ga, watasi ga itta toki ni ha mou urikire desita.
Why is 今日 followed by は?
What does 卵の特売 mean, and what is の doing here?
Why does the sentence say 特売でした? Isn’t 特売 a noun?
Yes, 特売 is a noun. In Japanese, nouns can be used as predicates with です / でした.
So:
- 特売です = it is a special sale
- 特売でした = it was a special sale
In context, 今日は卵の特売でした means:
- Today, eggs were on sale
- or There was a special sale on eggs today
This is very natural Japanese.
What does が mean in でしたが?
Here, が means but.
So:
- 今日は卵の特売でしたが、... = Today there was a sale on eggs, but...
This が connects two clauses and shows contrast.
It can sound a little softer or more formal than just using でも at the start of the next sentence.
Why is it 私が行った and not 私は行った?
In 私が行ったとき, the clause 私が行った modifies とき.
Inside this kind of embedded clause, が is often used to mark the subject:
- 私が行ったとき = when I went
Using は here is not impossible in every context, but が is the normal choice when you are simply identifying who did the action inside the clause.
So this is not saying as for me, I went with strong topic marking. It is simply marking I as the subject of went.
Why is it 行ったとき instead of 行くとき?
This is a very common question.
- 行くとき = when I go / when I’m about to go
- 行ったとき = when I went / when I had gone
In this sentence, the speaker is referring to the time they actually arrived or went to the store and found the eggs sold out. So 行ったとき is the natural choice.
A rough nuance here is:
- 私が行くときには = when I was going / when I was about to go
- 私が行ったときには = by the time I went / when I got there
What does ときに mean here? Is the に necessary?
とき means time or when.
So:
- 行ったとき = when I went
- 行ったときに = at the time when I went / when I went
The に marks a point in time. In many sentences with とき, this に is optional.
So these are both possible:
- 行ったとき、もう売り切れでした
- 行ったときに、もう売り切れでした
The version with に can sound a little more explicit, but the meaning is basically the same here.
Why is it ときには? What does には do?
には is に + は.
- に marks the time point
- は adds topic or contrast
So 行ったときには has a slight contrastive feeling, something like:
In this sentence, that contrast fits well: there was a sale, but by the time the speaker went, the eggs were already sold out.
What does もう mean here?
Here, もう means already.
So:
- もう売り切れでした = it was already sold out
This is different from the common negative pattern:
- もうない = there isn’t any more
- もう行かない = I won’t go anymore
With a positive statement like this one, もう usually means already.
Why is it 売り切れでした instead of 売り切れました?
Both are related, but they are slightly different in feel.
- 売り切れる is a verb meaning to sell out
- 売り切れ can also refer to the sold-out state
So:
- 売り切れました = it sold out
- 売り切れでした = it was sold out
In this sentence, the speaker is describing the condition at the time they went to the store: the eggs were already sold out. That is why 売り切れでした works very naturally.
Is the thing that was sold out explicitly stated in the second half?
Not directly, but it is understood from context.
The first half mentions 卵の特売. So in the second half, もう売り切れでした naturally means that the eggs on sale were sold out.
Japanese often leaves out things that are already clear from context. In English, we might repeat the eggs, but in Japanese that repetition is often unnecessary.
What is the overall structure of the sentence?
It breaks down like this:
- 今日は = as for today
- 卵の特売でしたが、 = there was a sale on eggs, but
- 私が行ったときには = when I went / by the time I went
- もう売り切れでした。 = they were already sold out
So the whole sentence is built as:
- topic/background
- contrast with が
- time clause
- result/state
That is a very common Japanese sentence pattern.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning JapaneseMaster Japanese — from kyou ha tamago no tokubai desita ga, watasi ga itta toki ni ha mou urikire desita to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions