Breakdown of Mein Bruder mag den Altbau mehr als den Neubau, obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat.
Questions & Answers about Mein Bruder mag den Altbau mehr als den Neubau, obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat.
What form is mag?
Mag is the 3rd person singular present tense of mögen.
Because the subject is mein Bruder (my brother), German uses the er/sie/es form:
- ich mag
- du magst
- er/sie/es mag
So Mein Bruder mag ... means My brother likes ...
Also, mögen is an irregular verb, which is why you get mag rather than something more predictable.
Why is it mein Bruder and not meinen Bruder?
Because mein Bruder is the subject of the sentence, so it is in the nominative case.
Bruder is masculine singular, and with a possessive word like mein, the nominative masculine form is:
- mein Bruder
If it were a direct object, then you would get:
- meinen Bruder
So here:
- Mein Bruder = the person doing the liking
Why is it den Altbau?
Because Altbau is the direct object of mag, and mögen takes the accusative case.
Altbau is masculine, so:
- nominative: der Altbau
- accusative: den Altbau
That is why German says:
- Mein Bruder mag den Altbau ...
not der Altbau.
Why is it den Neubau after mehr als?
Because it is still part of the comparison with the object of mag.
The full idea is:
- My brother likes the old building more than the new building.
In German, the second noun keeps the role it has in the comparison. Since den Altbau is an accusative object, den Neubau is also accusative here:
- den Altbau mehr als den Neubau
So als itself is not forcing den. The accusative comes from the fact that Neubau is being compared as another object of mag.
Why does it later change to der Neubau?
Because in the obwohl clause, der Neubau is now the subject:
- obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat
Here, the new building is the thing that has the elevator, so it must be in the nominative case:
- nominative masculine: der Neubau
So the sentence uses both forms of the same noun for different grammatical jobs:
- den Neubau = object
- der Neubau = subject
Why is it einen Aufzug?
Because Aufzug is the direct object of hat, and haben takes the accusative case.
Aufzug is masculine, so:
- nominative: ein Aufzug
- accusative: einen Aufzug
That is why the sentence says:
- einen Aufzug hat
How does mehr als work here?
Mehr als means more than.
In this sentence, it compares how much the brother likes two things:
- den Altbau mehr als den Neubau
- literally: the old building more than the new building
So the structure is:
- jemanden/etwas mehr mögen als ...
- to like someone/something more than ...
It is a very normal way to make a comparison.
Could I also say lieber instead of mehr?
Yes. A very natural alternative is:
- Mein Bruder mag den Altbau lieber als den Neubau.
Using lieber often sounds especially natural when talking about preference between two options.
So:
- mehr als = correct
- lieber als = also correct, and often very idiomatic
Both are possible, though lieber is often what learners hear first in preference sentences.
Why is hat at the end of the clause after obwohl?
Because obwohl introduces a subordinate clause, and in German subordinate clauses send the conjugated verb to the end.
So:
- main clause: Mein Bruder mag den Altbau ...
- subordinate clause: obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat
This is a key German word-order rule:
- obwohl, weil, dass, wenn, etc. usually send the verb to the end.
That is why you get:
- obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat
not:
- obwohl der Neubau hat einen Aufzug
Why is there a comma before obwohl?
Because in German, a subordinate clause is normally separated from the main clause by a comma.
So the comma in
- ..., obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat
is required.
This is one of the big punctuation differences from English: German uses commas very consistently to mark subordinate clauses.
Can the obwohl clause come first?
Yes. You can also say:
- Obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat, mag mein Bruder den Altbau mehr als den Neubau.
That is completely correct.
But notice what happens in the main clause after the subordinate clause comes first: the conjugated verb must still stay in second position, so you get:
- ..., mag mein Bruder ...
not:
- ..., mein Bruder mag ...
This is another important German word-order pattern.
What should I notice about Altbau and Neubau as words?
A few useful things:
- They are compound nouns:
- Alt
- Bau
- Neu
- Bau
- Alt
- German writes such compounds as one word.
- They are capitalized because they are nouns.
- Their gender is masculine because the final part, Bau, is masculine.
So:
- der Altbau
- der Neubau
This is a very common German pattern: the last part of a compound usually determines the gender and basic grammatical behavior.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Mein Bruder mag den Altbau mehr als den Neubau, obwohl der Neubau einen Aufzug hat to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions