Breakdown of Der Vermieter sagt, dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist, aber vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann.
Questions & Answers about Der Vermieter sagt, dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist, aber vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann.
Why is there a comma before dass?
In German, a subordinate clause introduced by dass must be separated from the main clause with a comma.
So:
- Der Vermieter sagt = main clause
- dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist ... = subordinate clause
That is why you write:
Der Vermieter sagt, dass ...
This is one of the most important comma rules in German.
Why does ist come at the end in dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist?
Because dass introduces a subordinate clause, and in German subordinate clauses the conjugated verb usually goes to the end.
Compare:
- Main clause: Der Vertrag ist nur befristet.
- Subordinate clause: ..., dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist.
So the verb ist moves from second position to the end of the clause.
Why does the word order stay verb-final after aber? Shouldn't kann come earlier?
No, because aber is still inside the dass-clause.
The whole subordinate clause is:
dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist, aber vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann
Even after aber, you are still inside a subordinate clause, so the verb still stays at the end.
That is why you get:
- ... befristet ist
- ... unbefristet werden kann
not main-clause word order.
Why is it werden kann and not kann werden?
Because in a subordinate clause with a modal verb, both verbs go to the end, and the infinitive usually comes before the conjugated modal verb.
Here:
- kann = conjugated modal verb
- werden = infinitive
So the normal order is:
... unbefristet werden kann
Compare:
- Main clause: Der Vertrag kann später unbefristet werden.
- Subordinate clause: ..., dass der Vertrag später unbefristet werden kann.
What exactly do befristet and unbefristet mean?
These are very common words in contract and job contexts.
- befristet = fixed-term, limited in duration
- unbefristet = open-ended, permanent, not limited by an end date
So:
- ein befristeter Vertrag = a fixed-term contract
- ein unbefristeter Vertrag = a permanent/open-ended contract
The prefix un- often makes a word negative or opposite in meaning, similar to un- in English words like unclear.
Why is there no adjective ending on befristet or unbefristet here?
Because they are not being used directly before a noun here. They are used predicatively, after verbs like sein or werden.
Compare:
Der Vertrag ist befristet.
No adjective ending, because befristet comes after ist.der befristete Vertrag
Here you do need an adjective ending, because the adjective comes before the noun.
The same applies to unbefristet:
- Der Vertrag kann unbefristet werden.
- ein unbefristeter Vertrag
What does nur mean here?
nur means only or just.
In this sentence, it emphasizes that the contract is only fixed-term at the moment, not already permanent.
So the idea is:
- right now: fixed-term
- maybe later: permanent/open-ended
Without nur, the sentence would still make sense, but nur adds the feeling of limitation.
Why is der Vertrag nominative, not accusative?
Because der Vertrag is the subject of the subordinate clause.
In:
dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist
the thing that is fixed-term is der Vertrag, so it is the subject.
Likewise in:
... aber vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann
the thing that can become open-ended is still der Vertrag.
So der Vertrag stays nominative.
A useful way to see it:
- Who/what is fixed-term? Der Vertrag
- Who/what can become open-ended? Der Vertrag
That makes it the subject.
Does werden here mean become, or is this a passive construction?
Here werden is best understood as become.
So:
unbefristet werden = to become open-ended/permanent
That said, in real-life usage this can sound close to a passive idea in English, because a contract does not literally decide by itself to become permanent. In practice, the meaning is that it can later be converted into a permanent contract.
So a natural English translation could be either:
- can later become permanent
- can later be made permanent
- can later be converted into an open-ended contract
But grammatically, in the German sentence, werden is part of unbefristet werden.
Why are both vielleicht and später there? Don't they mean similar things?
They do different jobs:
- vielleicht = maybe, perhaps
- später = later
So:
- vielleicht tells you it is uncertain
- später tells you the time is in the future
Together, vielleicht später means something like maybe later.
Can the sentence also be written with a second dass?
Yes. You could say:
Der Vermieter sagt, dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist, aber dass er vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann.
That is also grammatical.
However, German often leaves out the second dass if the structure is already clear. The original sentence sounds natural and less heavy.
If you add the second dass, many speakers would also add er to repeat the subject more clearly.
Why is there a comma before aber?
Because aber is connecting two clauses here:
- der Vertrag nur befristet ist
- (der Vertrag) vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann
German normally uses a comma before aber when it links clauses like this.
So the punctuation helps show the two parallel ideas:
- right now it is fixed-term
- but maybe later it can become open-ended
Could Der Vermieter sagt also be in a different tense?
Yes. The sentence is in the present tense because it reports what the landlord says now.
Possible variations:
- Der Vermieter sagte, dass ... = The landlord said that ...
- Der Vermieter hat gesagt, dass ... = The landlord has said that ...
The rest of the sentence would stay basically the same, with the dass-clause still using verb-final word order.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning GermanMaster German — from Der Vermieter sagt, dass der Vertrag nur befristet ist, aber vielleicht später unbefristet werden kann to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions