Breakdown of I dag lærer vi, hvordan man bruger komma og punktum, når man skriver længere beskeder.
Questions & Answers about I dag lærer vi, hvordan man bruger komma og punktum, når man skriver længere beskeder.
Why is the word order I dag lærer vi and not I dag vi lærer?
Because Danish main clauses usually follow the V2 rule: the finite verb comes in the second position.
So:
- I dag = first element
- lærer = second element, so it must come here
- vi = comes after the verb
That is why I dag lærer vi is correct.
Compare:
- Vi lærer i dag ... = normal subject-first order
- I dag lærer vi ... = time expression first, so the subject moves after the verb
This is very common in Danish.
What does man mean here?
Man is a very common Danish pronoun meaning one, you, or people in general.
In this sentence, it does not mean a male person. It is generic.
So:
- hvordan man bruger komma og punktum = how one uses commas and periods
- In natural English, this is often translated as how you use commas and periods
Danish uses man a lot in general statements, where English often prefers you.
Why is it hvordan man bruger instead of hvordan bruger man?
Because this is an embedded question or indirect question, not a direct question.
- Direct question: Hvordan bruger man komma og punktum?
- Embedded question: ... hvordan man bruger komma og punktum
In Danish, direct questions often have verb before subject, but embedded questions usually have subject before verb.
So:
- hvordan bruger man ...? = direct question
- hvordan man bruger ... = indirect question
That difference is very important in Danish word order.
Why is there a comma before hvordan and before når?
Those commas mark the beginning of subordinate clauses:
- hvordan man bruger komma og punktum
- når man skriver længere beskeder
In Danish, many writers use commas to separate subordinate clauses like this.
A useful extra note: Danish has had two accepted comma systems, so in some styles the comma before a subordinate clause can be omitted. But the version in your sentence is completely normal and easy to understand.
So the commas are there because the sentence contains extra clause units introduced by hvordan and når.
Why is it når here? Could it be da or hvis?
Here når means when in a general or repeated sense.
The idea is:
- when you write longer messages
- meaning whenever you write them, or in that situation in general
Compare:
- når = when, in general / whenever
- da = when, about one specific past event
- hvis = if
So in this sentence:
- når man skriver længere beskeder = when writing longer messages / when one writes longer messages
Using da would sound wrong here, because this is not one specific past occasion.
Why are there no articles before komma and punktum?
Because Danish often leaves out the article when talking about things in general, especially in explanations, categories, and school-style language.
So:
- komma og punktum = commas and periods / the comma and the full stop as concepts
If you wanted to talk about one specific punctuation mark, you could use the indefinite article:
- et komma
- et punktum
So the sentence is talking about punctuation generally, not about one single comma or one single period.
Why is it længere beskeder and not lange beskeder?
Because længere is the comparative form of lang.
- lang = long
- lange beskeder = long messages
- længere beskeder = longer messages
So the sentence specifically means messages that are longer, not just long.
Also, comparative forms like længere do not change the way ordinary adjectives do for gender or number here, so længere beskeder is the natural form.
What is the basic form of beskeder?
The basic form is en besked.
Its common forms are:
- en besked = a message
- beskeden = the message
- beskeder = messages
- beskederne = the messages
So længere beskeder simply means longer messages in the plural.
Why does the sentence start with I dag? Is that just emphasis?
Yes, putting I dag at the beginning gives it prominence.
It highlights today as the frame for the whole sentence:
- I dag lærer vi ... = Today, we are learning ...
Danish often places time expressions first when they set the scene. When that happens, the verb still has to stay in second position, which is why you get:
- I dag lærer vi ...
So it is both natural and slightly emphatic.
Can vi and man both be subjects in the same sentence like this?
Yes. That is completely normal.
In this sentence, the main clause has one subject:
- vi in I dag lærer vi
Then the subordinate clauses have a different, more general subject:
- man in hvordan man bruger ...
- man in når man skriver ...
So the structure is:
- we are learning
- about how people / you / one use punctuation
- when people / you / one write longer messages
The subject can change from clause to clause, just as it can in English.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning DanishMaster Danish — from I dag lærer vi, hvordan man bruger komma og punktum, når man skriver længere beskeder to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions