Breakdown of U lokativu razgovaramo o gradu, a u instrumentalu putujemo s prijateljicom.
Questions & Answers about U lokativu razgovaramo o gradu, a u instrumentalu putujemo s prijateljicom.
What grammar point is this sentence illustrating?
It is showing how different prepositions trigger different cases in Croatian:
- o + locative: razgovaramo o gradu = we are talking about the city
- s + instrumental: putujemo s prijateljicom = we are traveling with a female friend
It also includes the phrases u lokativu and u instrumentalu, which mean in the locative and in the instrumental.
Why do we say u lokativu and u instrumentalu instead of just lokativ and instrumental?
Because the preposition u usually means in and here it is used metaphorically, as in in the locative or in the instrumental.
So the case names themselves have to change form:
- lokativ → u lokativu
- instrumental → u instrumentalu
This is the locative singular form after u.
Why is it o gradu and not o grad?
Because the preposition o meaning about requires the locative case.
The noun is:
- nominative: grad = city
- locative singular: gradu
So:
- o gradu = about the city
You should think of o as a preposition that automatically calls for the locative.
Why is it s prijateljicom and not s prijateljica?
Because s meaning with requires the instrumental case.
The noun is:
- nominative: prijateljica = female friend
- instrumental singular: prijateljicom
So:
- s prijateljicom = with a female friend
Again, the preposition determines the case.
Why does u take the locative here? I thought u can also take the accusative.
Yes, u can take either the locative or the accusative, depending on meaning.
- u + locative = location, being in something
- u + accusative = motion into something
Here, u lokativu and u instrumentalu mean in the locative and in the instrumental, so this is a location/state idea, not motion. That is why the locative is used.
Compare:
- u gradu = in the city
- u grad = into the city (less common than u grad / u grad? Actually standard is u grad for motion with accusative)
What does a mean in this sentence?
A is a coordinating conjunction. In this sentence it has a contrastive or parallel meaning, something like:
- and
- while
- whereas
So the sentence sets up a comparison:
- In the locative, we talk about the city, and in the instrumental, we travel with a female friend.
It links two matching grammatical examples.
Why are the verbs razgovaramo and putujemo in the present tense?
Because Croatian often uses the present tense to state general facts or explain grammar rules.
Here the sentence is not talking about one specific real-life event. It is giving examples of how cases work, so present tense is natural:
- razgovaramo = we talk / we are talking
- putujemo = we travel / we are traveling
They are both 1st person plural forms, with the subject mi = we understood and left unstated.
Is gradu only a locative form?
No. Gradu can be both:
This is very common in Croatian: some case forms look the same.
How do you know which one it is? From the context, especially the preposition.
- o gradu must be locative, because o takes the locative.
- If you had something like prilazim gradu = I am approaching the city, that would be dative.
When do I use s and when do I use sa?
Both mean with, but sa is mainly used to make pronunciation easier.
You often hear sa before words beginning with certain consonants or consonant clusters, especially where s would be awkward to pronounce.
Examples:
- sa sestrom
- sa školom
- sa mnom
But here s prijateljicom is perfectly normal and standard, because it is easy to pronounce.
Does prijateljicom specifically mean a female friend?
Why is there no word for the or a in Croatian here?
Because Croatian does not have articles like English the and a/an.
So:
- grad can mean a city or the city
- prijateljica can mean a female friend or the female friend
The exact meaning depends on context.
Can the same noun appear in different cases depending on the preposition?
Yes, absolutely. The case is not a permanent property of the noun. It changes depending on its role in the sentence and on the preposition used.
For example, with grad:
- grad = nominative
- o gradu = locative, after o
- u gradu = locative, after u
- s gradom = instrumental, after s
And with prijateljica:
- prijateljica = nominative
- o prijateljici = locative
- s prijateljicom = instrumental
So the key question is not just what is the noun? but also what preposition or function does it have here?
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning CroatianMaster Croatian — from U lokativu razgovaramo o gradu, a u instrumentalu putujemo s prijateljicom to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions