Avui no hi ha cereals, però encara hi ha una taronja i una tassa de llet.

Breakdown of Avui no hi ha cereals, però encara hi ha una taronja i una tassa de llet.

un
a
no
not
avui
today
haver-hi
there be
la llet
the milk
i
and
però
but
de
of
encara
still
la tassa
the cup
el cereal
the cereal
la taronja
the orange

Questions & Answers about Avui no hi ha cereals, però encara hi ha una taronja i una tassa de llet.

What does hi ha mean in this sentence?

Hi ha is the Catalan way to say there is or there are when you mean that something exists or is available.

So:

  • no hi ha cereals = there isn’t any cereal / there are no cereals
  • hi ha una taronja = there is an orange
  • hi ha una tassa de llet = there is a cup of milk

It is a very common structure in Catalan, and you should learn it as a fixed expression: haver-hi.

Why does Catalan use ha even with plural cereals? Why not a plural verb?

In standard Catalan, the existential expression hi ha stays in the 3rd person singular, even if the thing after it is plural.

So Catalan says:

  • Hi ha cereals
  • Hi ha dues pomes
  • Hi ha molts llibres

not standard hi han

This is different from English, where we say there is for singular and there are for plural. In standard Catalan, hi ha works for both.

What is the function of hi in hi ha?

In modern Catalan, hi is part of the fixed existential expression haver-hi. For learners, the easiest approach is to treat hi ha as one chunk meaning there is / there are.

Historically, hi is a locative element, related to the idea of there, but in everyday learning you do not usually need to analyze it every time. Just remember:

  • hi ha = there is / there are
  • no hi ha = there is not / there are not
Why is there no article before cereals?

Because after hi ha, Catalan often uses a bare plural or an unmarked noun when talking about the presence or absence of things in a general, indefinite way.

So:

  • No hi ha cereals = There isn’t any cereal / There are no cereals

This sounds natural when you mean the food is unavailable, not a specific previously mentioned box or type.

If you used an article, the meaning would usually become more specific. Here the sentence is talking generally about what is available today.

What does encara mean here?

Here encara means still.

So:

  • però encara hi ha una taronja = but there is still an orange

It shows that although the cereal is gone, some food remains available.

Be careful: encara can have different uses depending on context, but in this sentence still is the best meaning.

Why is no placed before hi ha?

In Catalan, standard negation usually puts no directly before the verb.

So:

  • hi ha cereals = there is/are cereal
  • no hi ha cereals = there isn’t/aren’t any cereal

That is the normal position for simple negation.

Why do we have una taronja and una tassa, but just de llet without an article?

Taronja and tassa are singular countable nouns, so they take the indefinite article una:

  • una taronja = an orange
  • una tassa = a cup

But llet is a mass noun here, and after a measure expression Catalan normally says:

  • una tassa de llet = a cup of milk

not usually una tassa de la llet, unless you mean some specific milk already identified in the conversation.

So the structure is:

  • [measure/container] + de + noun
  • una tassa de llet
  • un got d’aigua
  • una mica de pa
Does cereals here really mean English cereal?

Yes, in this context cereals most naturally refers to breakfast cereal.

Even though cereals can also mean grains/cereals in a broader sense, the context of an orange and a cup of milk strongly suggests breakfast food. So a learner should understand it as cereal in the everyday English sense.

Why is hi ha repeated after però? Could it be omitted?

In this sentence, it is natural to repeat hi ha because the second part is a new clause:

  • Avui no hi ha cereals, però encara hi ha una taronja i una tassa de llet.

If you removed it, the sentence would not sound right in standard Catalan. The second clause needs its own verb.

So the repetition is normal and necessary here.

Why does the sentence start with Avui?

Avui means today, and putting it first sets the time frame immediately.

So the sentence begins by telling you that this is the situation today:

  • Avui no hi ha cereals... = Today there’s no cereal...

Catalan word order is somewhat flexible, so other orders are possible in some contexts, but starting with Avui is very natural because it gives the time information first.

How is hi ha pronounced?

The h in ha is silent.

In careful pronunciation, hi ha is roughly like ee AH.

A simple guide for an English speaker:

  • hiee
  • haa in father, with no h sound

So hi ha does not sound like English hee hah with a strong h. The h is not pronounced.

Why is it però and not some other word for but?

Però is the normal Catalan word for but when contrasting two statements.

Here the contrast is:

  • no cereal
  • but there is still an orange and some milk

So però is exactly the right conjunction.

A learner should simply memorize:

  • però = but
Is una taronja i una tassa de llet one combined idea, or two separate things?

They are two separate things joined by i (and):

  • una taronja
  • una tassa de llet

Both depend on the same hi ha:

  • encara hi ha una taronja i una tassa de llet

So the meaning is:

  • there is still an orange
  • and there is still a cup of milk

Catalan often uses one verb with two coordinated noun phrases like this.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
What's the best way to learn Catalan grammar?
Catalan grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Catalan

Master Catalan — from Avui no hi ha cereals, però encara hi ha una taronja i una tassa de llet to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods.

  • Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • AI tutor to answer your grammar questions