Bestanddelelyste is lank; hoe dit ook al sy, bepaal bestanddele raklewe.

Questions & Answers about Bestanddelelyste is lank; hoe dit ook al sy, bepaal bestanddele raklewe.

What exactly does bestanddelelyste mean, and what is the singular form?

Bestanddelelyste means ingredient lists.

The singular is bestanddelelys = ingredient list.

It is a compound noun:

  • bestanddele = ingredients
  • lys = list

Afrikaans usually writes compounds as one word, so instead of two separate words, you get bestanddelelys and bestanddelelyste.

Why is it is with a plural noun? Shouldn’t the verb change?

No. In Afrikaans, is is used for both singular and plural in the present tense of to be.

So both of these are correct:

  • Die lys is lank = The list is long
  • Die lyste is lank = The lists are long

That is why Bestanddelelyste is lank is completely normal.

Why is lank used for lists? Does it only refer to physical length?

Lank means long, and like English long, it can describe things such as lists, speeches, documents, and delays, not just physical objects.

So Bestanddelelyste is lank means the lists are long in the sense that they contain many items or take up a lot of space in writing.

What does hoe dit ook al sy mean?

It is an idiomatic expression meaning something like:

  • however
  • be that as it may
  • in any case
  • anyway

Literally, it is roughly however that may be, but you should treat it as a set expression rather than translating each word mechanically.

What does ook al do in hoe dit ook al sy?

In expressions like this, ook al helps create a concessive meaning such as however, no matter how, or even if that is so.

So hoe dit ook al sy does not mean how it also all is. That would be too literal and misleading. Here ook al is part of the idiom and helps give the sense of even so / be that as it may.

What is sy doing here? Does it mean his or her?

No. Here sy is not the possessive pronoun meaning his or her.

In this expression, sy comes from the verb wees = to be. So here it means be.

That is why hoe dit ook al sy feels similar to English be that as it may.

Why is the word order bepaal bestanddele raklewe instead of bestanddele bepaal raklewe?

Because Afrikaans usually follows a verb-second pattern in main clauses.

Basic order:

  • Bestanddele bepaal raklewe = Ingredients determine shelf life

But when another element is placed first, the finite verb comes before the subject:

  • Hoe dit ook al sy, bepaal bestanddele raklewe

This is the same pattern you see in sentences like:

  • Vandag koop ek brood = Today I am buying bread

So after the fronted phrase hoe dit ook al sy, the verb bepaal comes before the subject bestanddele.

What does raklewe mean, and why is it one word?

Raklewe means shelf life.

It is another compound noun:

  • rak = shelf
  • lewe = life

Afrikaans normally writes compounds as one word, so English shelf life becomes raklewe.

Why are there no articles like die or ’n in this sentence?

Because the sentence is making a general statement, not referring to one specific list or one specific ingredient.

Compare:

  • Bestanddelelyste is lank = Ingredient lists are long
  • Bestanddele bepaal raklewe = Ingredients determine shelf life

This article-less style is common in Afrikaans when speaking generally, just as English can also say Ingredients determine shelf life without the.

Why doesn’t bepaal change for the plural subject bestanddele?

Afrikaans verbs usually do not change according to person or number in the present tense.

So you get:

  • Die bestanddeel bepaal raklewe = The ingredient determines shelf life
  • Die bestanddele bepaal raklewe = The ingredients determine shelf life

The verb stays bepaal in both cases. This is one reason Afrikaans verb conjugation is simpler than English.

Why is there a semicolon in this sentence?

The semicolon links two closely related statements:

  • Bestanddelelyste is lank
  • hoe dit ook al sy, bepaal bestanddele raklewe

It shows a stronger break than a comma, but a closer connection than a full stop.

The meaning is basically:

  • Ingredient lists are long; however, ingredients determine shelf life.
Could the sentence be said in a simpler or more everyday way?

Yes. A more straightforward version could be:

  • Bestanddelelyste is lank, maar bestanddele bepaal raklewe.
  • Bestanddelelyste is lank; egter bepaal bestanddele raklewe.

The original hoe dit ook al sy sounds a bit more formal or idiomatic, like be that as it may in English.

AI Language TutorTry it ↗
Your avatar
“What's the best way to learn Afrikaans grammar?”
Afrikaans grammar becomes intuitive with practice. Focus on understanding the core patterns first — how sentences are structured, how verbs change form, and how words relate to each other. Our course breaks these concepts into small lessons so you can build understanding step by step.

Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor

Start learning Afrikaans

Master Afrikaans — from Bestanddelelyste is lank; hoe dit ook al sy, bepaal bestanddele raklewe to fluency

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
  • ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
  • ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
  • ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions