Breakdown of Er braucht Fäden für das Projekt, aber er hat keine.
er
he
haben
to have
aber
but
kein
no, not any
brauchen
to need
für
for
das Projekt
the project
der
who, which, that (relative pronoun; die, das)
der Faden
the thread
Questions & Answers about Er braucht Fäden für das Projekt, aber er hat keine.
This lesson is about the pronoun welche. Why does this sentence use keine instead?
Keine acts as the negative equivalent of welche in this context. If he did have some threads, the sentence would be ...aber er hat welche (but he has some). Because he has zero threads, we use the pronoun keine (none). Both words function as indefinite pronouns here, allowing us to avoid repeating the plural noun Fäden.
Does the pronoun keine take the same grammatical endings as the article keine?
Yes! Here, keine is a pronoun standing in for Fäden. It takes the plural accusative ending -e because it is the direct object of the verb hat. This is exactly the same ending it would take if it were used as a negative article right in front of the noun, as in er hat keine Fäden.
Is Fäden only used for sewing threads?
It is the plural of der Faden, which means thread or string. While it definitely applies to sewing, it is also used for spider webs, filaments, and metaphorical threads. For example, losing your train of thought is losing the Faden, and a central theme running through a project or story is called der rote Faden (the red thread).
Just to review: why doesn't the verb hat come immediately after aber?
Aber is a coordinating conjunction, which means it occupies position zero in the clause. The subject er is in position 1, placing the conjugated verb hat in its standard position 2. You would only put the verb before the subject if a word occupying position 1 (like the adverb deshalb) came first.
Learn Er braucht Fäden für das Projekt, aber er hat keine and more in German
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free