Breakdown of این پیشغذا گرم که هست، اما نباید آن را در این بشقاب سرو کنید.
این
this
آن
that
بودنbudan
to be
اماammâ
but
گرمgarm
warm, hot
بشقابboshghâb
plate
درdar
in
راrâ
definite direct object marker
بایدbâyad
must
کهke
that (conjunction)
پیشغذاpish-ghazâ
appetizer
سرو کردنserv kardan
to serve (food, drinks)
نبایدnabâyad
must not, should not
Questions & Answers about این پیشغذا گرم که هست، اما نباید آن را در این بشقاب سرو کنید.
How does the structure گرم که هست express that the appetizer "IS" warm?
By placing the adjective (گرم) right before که and following it with the verb (هست), you create a "concession." It acts like saying "warm, that it is," which acknowledges a fact before introducing a contrast with اما (but). This is a very natural Farsi pattern for saying "Sure, it is [X], but..."
Why use هست rather than است in the first half of the sentence?
است is generally used as a simple equals sign (A is B), while هست emphasizes that a state truly exists or is a confirmed fact. Because this specific topicalization structure is all about stressing the reality of the appetizer being warm before pivoting to a negative point, هست provides the necessary emphatic weight.
Why is the verb کنید used instead of بکنید after نباید?
The modal verb نباید (must not / shouldn't) requires the following verb to be in the subjunctive mood. For the compound verb سرو کردن (to serve), the subjunctive can be سرو بکنید or just سرو کنید. Dropping the بـ prefix is standard and extremely common in the subjunctive form of compound verbs.
Why do we need آن را in the second clause if the appetizer was already the subject of the first clause?
Just like English uses the pronoun "it" in "you shouldn't serve it," Farsi uses آن. Because "it" is receiving the action of being served, it is a direct object. Since we are talking about a specific, previously mentioned appetizer, it is a definite direct object and must be followed by the object marker را.
Learn این پیشغذا گرم که هست، اما نباید آن را در این بشقاب سرو کنید and more in Farsi
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free