O erro não é meu, mas a culpa é dele.

Questions & Answers about O erro não é meu, mas a culpa é dele.

How does the word mas connect the two parts of this sentence?
The word mas translates to "but". It simply links the two contrasting halves of the sentence together. You do not need to change the word order or the verb forms in either half when you use it.
Why is "mine" translated as meu but "his" is translated as dele?
The word meu is a possessive word that matches the masculine noun erro. For "his", you might expect a similar word like seu. However, in Portugal, seu is often used for "yours" (when speaking formally). To avoid confusion, Portuguese speakers almost always say dele (which literally means "of him") to mean "his".
Why do we use é here instead of está for the word "is"?
The verb ser (which gives us é) is used to describe facts, identities, or origins. Saying who made a mistake or who is to blame is treated as a permanent fact about that event, so we use é rather than está (which is for temporary states).
Could I just say culpa instead of a culpa?
No, in Portuguese you almost always need the definite article (like o or a) before a noun. The word culpa is feminine, so it takes a. Even in sentences where English drops the word "the", Portuguese usually keeps it before nouns like erro (mistake) and culpa (fault).

Learn O erro não é meu, mas a culpa é dele and more in Portuguese

All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.

  • Practice with interactive exercises
  • Track your progress with spaced repetition
  • Learn at your own pace — completely free