Question 1

Why is the pronoun o placed before posso instead of attached to the verbs?

Accepted Answer

In a verbal complex like posso destrancar (auxiliary verb + infinitive), a pronoun typically goes after one of the verbs. However, the negative word Não acts as a magnetic word. It pulls the pronoun to the very front, forcing it before the auxiliary verb posso.

Question 2

If the sentence were positive, how would the placement of o change?

Accepted Answer

Without Não pulling it to the front, you would have two options. You could attach it to the auxiliary verb (Posso-o destrancar) or to the infinitive (Posso destrancá-lo). Notice as a quick refresher that attaching o to an infinitive drops the verb's final -r and changes the pronoun to -lo.

Question 3

Are the two instances of o in this sentence doing the same job?

Accepted Answer

No, they are entirely different types of words. The first o in Não o posso is a direct object pronoun meaning "it," which takes the place of the padlock. The second o in o cadeado is simply the definite article meaning "the."

Question 4

Why do we use está instead of é for a padlock that is broken?

Accepted Answer

We use está (from the verb estar) because estragado describes a physical state or the result of an action, rather than an inherent, unchangeable characteristic of the padlock itself. Even if the padlock stays broken for a long time, temporary conditions and states of repair always use estar.

Não o posso destrancar porque o cadeado está estragado.

Breakdown of Não o posso destrancar porque o cadeado está estragado.

Questions & Answers about Não o posso destrancar porque o cadeado está estragado.

Learn Não o posso destrancar porque o cadeado está estragado and more in Portuguese