Breakdown of O pássaro viveu em cativeiro; apesar disso, voltou a voar.
em
in, on, at
viver
to live
voar
to fly
o pássaro
the bird
voltar a
to do again, to resume (+ infinitive)
o cativeiro
the captivity
apesar disso
despite that
Questions & Answers about O pássaro viveu em cativeiro; apesar disso, voltou a voar.
How is apesar disso built, and could I use mesmo assim or ainda assim here instead?
Apesar disso combines the preposition apesar de (despite / in spite of) with the neuter pronoun isso (that), where de + isso contracts to disso. Here, isso points back to the entire previous statement — the fact that the bird lived in captivity. You could easily swap apesar disso for mesmo assim (even so) or ainda assim (still / even so) in this sentence with practically no change in meaning. In both speech and writing, Brazilians also very often pair these connectors with mas: O pássaro viveu em cativeiro, mas, apesar disso, voltou a voar.
What is the difference between using apesar disso and apesar de?
Apesar de needs something after it — a noun or an infinitive verb — whereas apesar disso points backward to something already stated, because isso already fills that slot. In this sentence, apesar disso looks back at O pássaro viveu em cativeiro. If you wanted to join the two ideas directly using apesar de, you would follow it with an infinitive: Apesar de ter vivido em cativeiro, o pássaro voltou a voar (Despite having lived in captivity, the bird flew again).
Why does voltou a voar mean "flew again" rather than "returned to fly"?
In Portuguese, voltar a + infinitive is a very natural way to express doing something again or resuming an action. While you can use adverbs like de novo or novamente (voou de novo / voou novamente), voltar a is especially common when someone or something returns to a previous habit or natural state. Notice the preposition a between voltar and the infinitive; when voltar literally means going back to a place in order to do something, Brazilians use para instead (Voltei para pegar as chaves — I went back to get the keys).
Why is there no article in em cativeiro?
Em cativeiro (in captivity) is a fixed expression that describes a general state or condition, much like em liberdade (in the wild / free) or em perigo (in danger). Because it describes how the bird lived rather than a specific physical place, it omits the definite article o. Saying no cativeiro (em + o) would sound as if you were pointing to a particular enclosure already mentioned in the conversation.
Learn O pássaro viveu em cativeiro; apesar disso, voltou a voar and more in Portuguese
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓ Practice with interactive exercises
- ✓ Track your progress with spaced repetition
- ✓Learn at your own pace — completely free