Question 1

Why do we use Lui here instead of just saying Fuma una sigaretta?

Accepted Answer

In Italian, subject pronouns like lui (he) are usually dropped because the verb ending already tells us who is doing the action. Including it here adds emphasis, meaning specifically he is smoking the cigarette, perhaps in contrast to someone else doing something else.

Question 2

How would we change this sentence to say 'One smokes a cigarette in the garden' using the new impersonal si?

Accepted Answer

You would drop lui and use the impersonal si before the verb, making it Si fuma una sigaretta in giardino. This changes the meaning from a specific person smoking to a general statement like 'People smoke a cigarette in the garden' or 'One smokes a cigarette in the garden.'

Question 3

Why is it in giardino and not nel giardino?

Accepted Answer

For common rooms and areas around the home, like the garden (giardino), kitchen (cucina), or living room (salotto), Italian typically uses the preposition in by itself, without combining it with a word for 'the'. You would generally only say nel giardino if you were talking about a specific, described garden, like Marco's garden.

Lui fuma una sigaretta in giardino.

Breakdown of Lui fuma una sigaretta in giardino.

Questions & Answers about Lui fuma una sigaretta in giardino.

Learn Lui fuma una sigaretta in giardino and more in Italian