Breakdown of Den nya grannen ska vara fotograf, och hennes syster ska ha öppnat ett café vid torget.
Questions & Answers about Den nya grannen ska vara fotograf, och hennes syster ska ha öppnat ett café vid torget.
What does ska mean here? Is it future, obligation, or something else?
Here ska most likely expresses reported information / assumption, not a strong future meaning and not direct obligation.
So:
- Den nya grannen ska vara fotograf = The new neighbor is said to be a photographer / apparently the new neighbor is a photographer
- hennes syster ska ha öppnat ett café = her sister is said to have opened a café
This use of ska often means:
- I’ve heard that...
- Apparently...
- It is said that...
In other contexts, ska can also mean:
- will / going to
- shall / must / is supposed to
So the exact meaning depends a lot on context.
Why is it den nya grannen and not just grannen or den grannen?
Den nya grannen means the new neighbor.
This phrase shows a very common Swedish pattern called double definiteness:
- den = the
- nya = new
- grannen = the neighbor
When a noun is definite and has an adjective before it, Swedish usually marks definiteness twice:
- with den/det/de
- with the definite ending on the noun
So:
- granne = a neighbor
- grannen = the neighbor
- den nya grannen = the new neighbor
You normally cannot just say nya grannen in standard Swedish here.
Why is the adjective nya and not ny?
Because the adjective is in its definite form.
Compare:
- en ny granne = a new neighbor
- den nya grannen = the new neighbor
When an adjective comes before a definite noun, Swedish usually uses the -a form of the adjective:
- den nya bilen = the new car
- det stora huset = the big house
- de gamla böckerna = the old books
So nya here is not plural only; it is also the normal form with definite nouns.
Why does grannen still have -en if den already means the?
Because Swedish normally uses both:
- a separate definite word: den
- a definite ending on the noun: -en
This is exactly the double definiteness pattern.
So:
- granne = neighbor
- grannen = the neighbor
- den nya grannen = the new neighbor
English only marks definiteness once with the, but Swedish often marks it twice when there is an adjective.
Why is there no article before fotograf?
After vara (to be), Swedish often omits the article when talking about someone’s profession, role, religion, or nationality.
So:
- Hon är läkare = She is a doctor
- Han är student = He is a student
- Hon är fotograf = She is a photographer
That is why the sentence has:
- ska vara fotograf
not usually:
- ska vara en fotograf
Using en here can sound different, often more like one photographer / a certain photographer, or it can feel less like the normal “profession” pattern.
Why is it ska vara fotograf but ska ha öppnat?
Because the two parts refer to different kinds of information:
- ska vara fotograf = someone is said to be a photographer
- ska ha öppnat = someone is said to have opened a café
The second part uses ha + supine (ha öppnat) because it refers to something completed earlier.
So:
- ska vara = is said to be
- ska ha öppnat = is said to have opened
This is similar to English:
- She is said to be a photographer
- She is said to have opened a café
What form is öppnat?
Öppnat is the supine form of the verb öppna.
In Swedish, the supine is used with har/hade/ha to make perfect-type constructions:
- har öppnat = has opened
- hade öppnat = had opened
- ska ha öppnat = is said to have opened / will have opened, depending on context
Important distinction:
- öppna = infinitive
- öppnar = present
- öppnade = past
- öppnat = supine
So in ska ha öppnat, öppnat is there because it follows ha.
Why is it ett café and not en café?
Because café is a neuter noun in Swedish:
- ett café = a café
- caféet = the café
Swedish nouns have grammatical gender, and many learners need to memorize whether a noun is en or ett.
So here:
- ett café is correct
Why is it hennes syster without any article?
Because possessives like min, din, hans, hennes, vår already make the noun definite in meaning.
So:
- en syster = a sister
- systern = the sister
- hennes syster = her sister
You do not add en or a definite ending here:
- not en hennes syster
- not hennes systern
This is similar to English: we say her sister, not the her sister.
Why is it vid torget and not just vid torg?
Because torget means the square / the marketplace, and Swedish often uses the definite form in places where English may or may not.
So:
- ett torg = a square
- torget = the square
vid torget means:
- by the square
- near the square
In many real contexts, this refers to the central or locally known square, so the definite form is natural.
What exactly does vid mean here?
Vid usually means by, beside, at, or near, depending on context.
Here vid torget means something like:
- by the square
- near the square
It suggests location close to the square, but not necessarily directly on it.
Compare roughly:
- på torget = on the square / in the square area
- vid torget = by the square / next to the square
Why is the word order ska vara / ska ha öppnat after the subject?
Because this is a normal main clause in Swedish.
Basic Swedish main-clause word order is often:
subject + verb + ...
So:
- Den nya grannen = subject
- ska = finite verb
- vara fotograf = rest of the verb phrase
And:
- hennes syster = subject
- ska = finite verb
- ha öppnat ett café vid torget = rest of the verb phrase
Swedish is a V2 language, which means the finite verb usually comes in the second position in main clauses. Since the subject comes first here, the verb follows it normally.
Could I say Den nya grannen är fotograf instead?
Yes, but it would mean something different.
Den nya grannen är fotograf = The new neighbor is a photographer
This sounds like a direct statement of fact.Den nya grannen ska vara fotograf = The new neighbor is said to be a photographer / apparently is a photographer
This sounds less direct, more like reported information.
So the difference is mainly certainty / source of information.
Why is there an och here instead of starting a new sentence?
Because Swedish, like English, can join two related clauses with och (and):
- Den nya grannen ska vara fotograf
- och hennes syster ska ha öppnat ett café vid torget
This simply connects two pieces of information. You could also split them into two sentences, but using och makes them feel more connected.
Is ska ha öppnat always “is said to have opened”?
No. Ska ha + supine can have different meanings depending on context.
Common possibilities include:
- reported information: is said to have opened
- assumption / inference: should have opened / is supposed to have opened
- in some contexts, a more literal future-related meaning can appear
In this sentence, the most natural reading is the reported-information one: her sister is said to have opened a café.
So the structure is not tied to just one translation; context decides the best English wording.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SwedishMaster Swedish — from Den nya grannen ska vara fotograf, och hennes syster ska ha öppnat ett café vid torget to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions