Breakdown of Mi sobrina no siempre obedece a la profesora, pero normalmente se porta bien en clase.
Questions & Answers about Mi sobrina no siempre obedece a la profesora, pero normalmente se porta bien en clase.
Why is there an a in obedece a la profesora? In English we just say obey the teacher.
Because Spanish uses the personal a before a person who is the object of the verb.
Here, la profesora is the person being obeyed, so Spanish says:
obedecer a la profesora
Even though English does not use to, this a does not mean the same thing as English to here. It is just a normal Spanish grammar feature with people.
Compare:
- Obedece a su madre. = He/She obeys his/her mother.
- Obedece las reglas. = He/She obeys the rules.
With a person, a is very common.
Is la profesora an indirect object because of the a?
No. In this sentence, la profesora is still the direct object of obedecer.
The a can be confusing for English speakers, because it looks like an indirect object marker, but here it is simply the personal a.
So:
- Mi sobrina obedece a la profesora. = My niece obeys the teacher.
The teacher is the one being obeyed, so she is the direct object.
Why is the verb obedece and not something else like obedeces or obedecen?
Because the subject is mi sobrina, which is third person singular: she.
So the present tense of obedecer here is:
Since mi sobrina = ella, the correct form is obedece.
Why does the sentence say no siempre instead of siempre no?
Because no siempre is the normal way to say not always in Spanish.
- No siempre obedece = She does not always obey.
Siempre no is not the usual neutral phrasing. It can sound odd or very marked depending on context.
So for ordinary statements:
- no siempre = not always
- siempre = always
- normalmente = normally / usually
What does se porta bien mean exactly?
Portarse bien means to behave well.
So:
- se porta bien = he/she behaves well
- me porto bien = I behave well
- te portas bien = you behave well
It is a very common expression, especially for talking about children.
You can also say:
- portarse mal = to behave badly
So in this sentence:
normalmente se porta bien en clase = she usually behaves well in class
Why is there a se in se porta bien? What does it do?
Because portarse is a pronominal verb. The se is part of the verb expression.
This is important because:
- portar by itself usually means to carry or to wear
- portarse means to behave
So:
Why does it say en clase and not en la clase?
En clase is the usual idiomatic way to mean in class / during class in a general sense.
So:
- se porta bien en clase = she behaves well in class
If you say en la clase, it sounds more specific, like:
- in the specific class
- in the classroom
- in that particular lesson
In many cases, Spanish leaves out the article in fixed expressions like this:
- en clase
- en casa
- de noche
What is the difference between no siempre and normalmente in this sentence?
They are similar in topic, but not the same in meaning.
- no siempre = not always
- normalmente = normally / usually
So the sentence says:
- she doesn’t always obey the teacher
- but she usually behaves well in class
This creates a nice contrast: she may not obey every time, but overall her behaviour is generally good.
Why is pero used here? Are the two ideas really opposite?
Yes, pero introduces a contrast.
The contrast is:
- not always obeying the teacher sounds negative
- usually behaving well sounds more positive
So pero works like but in English:
She doesn’t always obey the teacher, but she usually behaves well in class.
The two ideas are not complete opposites, but they pull in different directions, which is exactly why pero fits well.
Why is it mi sobrina if sobrina is feminine? Why not a different form of my?
Does la profesora specifically mean a female teacher?
Yes. Profesora is the feminine form, so it refers to a female teacher.
- el profesor = the male teacher
- la profesora = the female teacher
In Spain, using the gendered profession noun like this is completely normal.
Why is the present tense used here?
Because the sentence describes habitual actions, not a single event happening right now.
Spanish often uses the simple present for routines, habits, and general truths.
So here:
- no siempre obedece = she does not always obey
- normalmente se porta bien = she usually behaves well
This is the same idea as English using the present simple for habits:
- She doesn’t always obey
- She usually behaves well
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from Mi sobrina no siempre obedece a la profesora, pero normalmente se porta bien en clase to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions