Breakdown of Mi abuela hace flan algunos domingos, pero mi hija prefiere natillas de vainilla.
Questions & Answers about Mi abuela hace flan algunos domingos, pero mi hija prefiere natillas de vainilla.
Why does Spanish use mi abuela and mi hija instead of something like la abuela mía or la hija mía here?
In normal, neutral Spanish, the possessive adjective usually goes before the noun:
- mi abuela
- mi hija
This is the most common way to say my grandmother and my daughter.
The longer pattern la abuela mía / la hija mía does exist, but it is much less neutral and often sounds more emphatic, emotional, or stylistically marked. A learner should usually choose:
- mi + noun
So in this sentence, mi abuela and mi hija are the standard choices.
Why is there no article before mi abuela or mi hija?
In Spanish, you normally do not use an article with a possessive adjective before a noun.
So Spanish says:
- mi abuela
- mi hija
not:
- la mi abuela
- la mi hija
This is different from English in some older or poetic styles, but in modern standard Spanish, mi, tu, su, etc. already do the job of marking possession, so no article is needed.
Why is it hace flan? Doesn’t hacer usually mean to do?
Yes, hacer often means to do or to make, and here it means to make.
In Spanish, hacer is very commonly used for preparing food, especially in a general sense:
- hacer flan
- hacer una tortilla
- hacer una tarta
So Mi abuela hace flan means My grandmother makes flan.
You could sometimes use another verb like preparar or cocinar, but hacer is extremely natural here.
What tense are hace and prefiere, and why is the present tense used?
Both verbs are in the present indicative:
The present tense is used here because the sentence describes:
- a habitual action: Mi abuela hace flan algunos domingos
- a general preference: mi hija prefiere natillas de vainilla
Spanish uses the simple present very often for things that happen regularly or are generally true, just like English does in sentences such as My grandmother makes flan and my daughter prefers vanilla custard.
Why does it say algunos domingos instead of los domingos?
There is an important difference:
- los domingos = on Sundays / every Sunday / Sundays in general
- algunos domingos = on some Sundays
So:
- Mi abuela hace flan los domingos = she does it regularly on Sundays
- Mi abuela hace flan algunos domingos = she does it only on certain Sundays, not all of them
In this sentence, algunos domingos shows that the action is occasional, not a fixed every-Sunday habit.
Why is flan singular but natillas plural?
This is mainly about how these foods are commonly referred to in Spanish.
- flan is normally treated as a singular noun: hacer flan, comer flan
- natillas is very often used in the plural in Spanish, even when talking about the dessert in a general sense
So prefiere natillas de vainilla is a very natural way to say she prefers that dessert.
This kind of thing is common across languages: some food words behave differently in number, and the most natural form is not always what an English speaker might expect.
Why is it natillas de vainilla and not an adjective like natillas vainilladas or vainilla natillas?
In Spanish, flavors are very often expressed with de + noun:
- helado de chocolate
- pastel de limón
- natillas de vainilla
So de vainilla means vanilla-flavored or with vanilla.
This structure is much more normal than trying to place vainilla directly before the noun. Spanish does not use noun-noun combinations the way English often does. English says vanilla custard, but Spanish usually prefers:
- natillas de vainilla
Why is it prefiere and not prefera or something more regular?
Because preferir is a stem-changing verb.
Its infinitive is preferir, but in the present tense the e in the stem changes to ie in most forms:
- yo prefiero
- tú prefieres
- él/ella prefiere
- nosotros/nosotras preferimos
- vosotros/vosotras preferís
- ellos/ellas prefieren
So mi hija prefiere means my daughter prefers.
This is a very common type of verb pattern in Spanish, and preferir follows it.
Why is pero used here?
Pero means but and connects the two parts of the sentence:
- Mi abuela hace flan algunos domingos
- pero mi hija prefiere natillas de vainilla
It introduces a contrast: the grandmother makes one dessert, but the daughter likes a different one better.
This is the normal conjunction to use for simple contrast. A learner should think of pero as the straightforward equivalent of English but in sentences like this.
Do we have to say mi abuela and mi hija, or could Spanish leave out the subjects?
Spanish often omits subject pronouns like yo, tú, ella, because the verb ending usually makes the subject clear. But that does not mean you normally omit a full noun subject like mi abuela or mi hija if you want to mention who is doing the action.
So this sentence naturally includes the nouns:
- Mi abuela hace flan...
- ...mi hija prefiere...
If the people were already clear from context, Spanish could sometimes avoid repeating them, but in a sentence like this, including both subjects is perfectly natural and helps make the contrast clear.
Could the word order be different?
Yes, Spanish word order is somewhat flexible, but the version here is the most neutral and natural:
You might hear or read other orders for emphasis, such as:
- Algunos domingos mi abuela hace flan...
This puts a little more focus on some Sundays.
But for a learner, the original order is an excellent model: subject + verb + object/complement.
Is vainilla just a noun here, or is it acting like an adjective?
Grammatically, vainilla is a noun, and in de vainilla it stays a noun.
The structure is:
- natillas
- de
- vainilla
- de
So rather than turning vainilla into an adjective, Spanish uses a prepositional phrase to describe the type or flavor of the dessert.
English often uses nouns directly before other nouns, as in vanilla custard, but Spanish usually avoids that pattern and prefers de + noun.
Would this sentence sound natural in Spain specifically?
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning SpanishMaster Spanish — from Mi abuela hace flan algunos domingos, pero mi hija prefiere natillas de vainilla to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions