Breakdown of На этом уроке мы не будем писать, а будем читать вслух.
Questions & Answers about На этом уроке мы не будем писать, а будем читать вслух.
Why is it на этом уроке and not в этом уроке?
With урок, Russian usually uses на when talking about something happening during a lesson/class.
- на уроке = in class / during the lesson
- на этом уроке = in this lesson / during this class
Using в этом уроке would more likely suggest inside the lesson as a unit of content, for example inside a textbook lesson, not the normal idea of what happens in class.
So here на этом уроке means during this lesson.
Why do we say этом уроке? What case is that?
This is the prepositional case.
The preposition на often takes the prepositional case when it means on / at / in a location or setting.
So:
- этот урок = this lesson
- на этом уроке = in/during this lesson
Both words change:
- этот → этом
- урок → уроке
This is the normal masculine singular prepositional pattern.
Why is the future written as не будем писать instead of using one future verb?
Because писать is an imperfective verb, and the future of imperfective verbs is normally formed with:
- быть in the future + infinitive
So:
- будем писать = we will be writing / we will write
- не будем писать = we will not write
This is called the compound future.
Russian does this because imperfective verbs describe an action as a process, activity, or repeated action, not as a completed result.
Why is it писать and not написать?
Because the sentence is talking about the activity done in class, not about producing a finished result.
- писать = to write, to be writing, to do writing
- написать = to write something and finish it
In a classroom sentence like this, the speaker means:
- we will not be doing writing
- we will be doing reading aloud
So the imperfective писать fits better than the perfective написать.
Why is it будем читать, not прочитаем?
For the same reason: читать is imperfective and focuses on the activity of reading.
- будем читать = we will read / we will be reading
- прочитаем = we will read and finish it
Here the teacher is describing what kind of work the class will do, not saying they will finish reading a particular text. So будем читать is the natural choice.
What does а mean here? Why not но or и?
Here а marks a contrast:
- не будем писать, а будем читать = we will not write, but rather read
It is not exactly the same as но.
- но often means but in the sense of contradiction
- а often means whereas / while / but instead
In this sentence, а is very natural because the speaker is contrasting one class activity with another.
So the meaning is:
- not writing, but reading aloud instead
Could Russian leave out the second будем?
Sometimes Russian can omit repeated words, but here repeating будем sounds natural and clear:
- мы не будем писать, а будем читать вслух
This gives a nice balance:
- не будем писать
- будем читать
If you remove the second будем, the sentence may sound less complete or shift the structure. Repeating it makes the contrast stronger and cleaner.
What does читать вслух mean exactly?
Читать вслух means to read aloud.
- читать = to read
- вслух = aloud, out loud
So будем читать вслух means we will read out loud, not silently.
This is a very common expression in Russian:
- читать вслух
- сказать вслух = to say out loud
Why is вслух one word?
Why is there no object after писать or читать?
Because in context, Russian often leaves the object unstated if it is obvious or unimportant.
So:
- писать can mean to do writing
- читать can mean to do reading
In a classroom context, this sounds perfectly natural. The sentence is about the type of activity, not about a specific thing being written or read.
If needed, you could add an object:
- будем читать текст вслух = we will read the text aloud
But it is not necessary here.
Is the word order important? Could the sentence be arranged differently?
Russian word order is flexible, but this order is very natural:
- На этом уроке sets the scene first: during this lesson
- мы gives the subject: we
- не будем писать, а будем читать вслух gives the contrast
Other orders are possible, but they change the emphasis. For example:
Мы на этом уроке не будем писать, а будем читать вслух
More emphasis on we.Читать вслух на этом уроке мы будем, а не писать
Much stronger contrast, more marked style.
The original sentence is the most neutral and teacher-like.
Do we really need the pronoun мы here?
Not always. Russian often drops subject pronouns when the verb ending already shows the subject.
So you could say:
- На этом уроке не будем писать, а будем читать вслух.
This still clearly means we will not write, but will read aloud.
However, including мы can make the sentence:
- clearer
- slightly more explicit
- more natural in some teaching or explanatory contexts
So мы is optional here, but perfectly normal.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning RussianMaster Russian — from На этом уроке мы не будем писать, а будем читать вслух to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions