Learn Hardcore Portuguese (Brazil): Paulo está triste porque ele não pode jantar hoje. - Paulo is sad because he cannot have dinner today.

In Portuguese, está indicates a temporary state or condition (something that can change), whereas é indicates a more permanent characteristic. Since Paulo’s sadness is seen as a temporary feeling, está is used.

Why do we use porque instead of por que in this sentence?

In Portuguese, porque (written as one word) typically means because, introducing the reason for something. On the other hand, por que (two words) is used for why (as in a question) or means for which in some constructions. Since we are giving a reason for Paulo’s sadness, porque is correct here.

Could we omit ele since we already mentioned Paulo?

In Portuguese, subject pronouns can be omitted when the subject is clear from context, especially with conjugated verbs. However, including ele here helps maintain clarity and places emphasis on Paulo. It’s a stylistic choice: both forms are possible, but the sentence with ele is perfectly natural and common.

Why do we use the present tense form pode instead of the past tense pôde?

The verb pode is the present-tense conjugation of poder for ele (he). It expresses that Paulo cannot have dinner today, implying a current or immediate situation. Pôde refers to the past tense (he could/couldn’t), which doesn’t fit here.

What does jantar specifically mean in this context?

Jantar means to have dinner or to dine. It can function both as a verb (jantar) and as a noun (o jantar, meaning dinner). In this sentence, the focus is on Paulo’s inability to have dinner today.

Your questions are stored by us to improve Elon.io

Breakdown of Paulo está triste porque ele não pode jantar hoje.

Questions & Answers about Paulo está triste porque ele não pode jantar hoje.

You've reached your AI usage limit