Breakdown of Pater putat canistrum a serva ad triclinium portatum esse, sed catinum adhuc in culina manere.
Questions & Answers about Pater putat canistrum a serva ad triclinium portatum esse, sed catinum adhuc in culina manere.
Why is canistrum in the accusative, even though it seems to be the thing being carried?
Because after putat (he thinks), Latin often uses an indirect statement.
In an indirect statement:
- the subject of the reported idea goes into the accusative
- the verb goes into an infinitive
So in Pater putat canistrum ... portatum esse:
- Pater putat = The father thinks
- canistrum ... portatum esse = that the basket has been carried
Here canistrum is the subject of the infinitive portatum esse, but in Latin indirect statement that subject is accusative.
Why is the verb portatum esse instead of a normal finite verb like portatum est?
Again, this is because of indirect statement after putat.
Latin does not usually say:
- Pater putat canistrum portatum est
Instead it says:
- Pater putat canistrum portatum esse
That infinitive phrase means that the basket has been carried.
More specifically:
- portatum = the perfect passive participle
- esse = to be
Together, portatum esse is the perfect passive infinitive: to have been carried.
Why is it portatum and not portatus or portatam?
Because portatum agrees with canistrum.
Canistrum is:
- neuter
- singular
So the participle must also be:
- neuter singular → portatum
If the noun were different, the participle would change:
- servus portatus esse
- serva portata esse
- canistrum portatum esse
The participle agrees with the accusative subject of the indirect statement.
What does a serva mean, and why is serva ablative?
A serva means by the slave-girl or by the female slave.
In a passive construction, the person who does the action is often expressed with:
- a/ab + ablative
So:
- a serva = by the slave-girl
- ab amico = by the friend
This is called the personal agent.
Here the sentence is passive:
- canistrum ... portatum esse = the basket to have been carried so Latin uses a serva to show who carried it.
Why is it ad triclinium?
Because ad + accusative expresses movement toward a place.
So:
- ad triclinium = to the dining room
This fits the verb portatum esse because the basket is being carried to somewhere.
Compare:
- in culina = in the kitchen → location
- ad triclinium = to the dining room → motion toward
Why is catinum also accusative?
For the same reason as canistrum: it is the subject of another indirect statement depending on putat.
The second part is:
- sed catinum adhuc in culina manere
This means:
- but that the dish is still remaining in the kitchen
So:
- catinum = accusative subject of manere
- manere = infinitive
Both parts depend on putat:
- Pater putat [canistrum ... portatum esse], sed [catinum ... manere].
In smoother English:
Father thinks that the basket has been carried by the slave-girl to the dining room, but that the dish is still in the kitchen.
Why is it manere and not manet?
Because this is still part of what the father thinks, so Latin keeps using the infinitive for indirect statement.
- manet would mean it remains
- manere means to remain
After putat, Latin wants:
- accusative subject + infinitive
So:
- catinum adhuc in culina manere = that the dish is still remaining in the kitchen
Why doesn’t the second clause use esse too?
Because manere already is the verb of that clause.
In the first clause, the passive idea needs:
- portatum esse = to have been carried
But in the second clause:
- manere by itself already means to remain / to stay
So there is no need for another esse.
Latin is saying:
- the basket to have been carried
- the dish to remain
Both are normal infinitive constructions, just with different verbs.
How do the tenses work in portatum esse and manere?
In indirect statement, infinitive tense is usually understood relative to the main verb, not as an absolute tense in the same way as English finite verbs.
Here the main verb is putat = he thinks.
portatum esse is a perfect infinitive, so it shows action already completed relative to putat
→ he thinks that the basket has been carried / was carriedmanere is a present infinitive, so it shows action happening at the same time as putat
→ he thinks that the dish is still remaining / is still in the kitchen
So the contrast is:
- the basket has already been taken
- the dish is still there now
What does adhuc mean here?
Adhuc means still, up to this point, or so far.
In this sentence:
- catinum adhuc in culina manere
it shows that the dish has not yet been moved and is still in the kitchen.
It adds an idea of continuation:
- not just it is in the kitchen
- but it is still in the kitchen
Why is it in culina with the ablative?
Because in + ablative usually means in or on in the sense of location.
So:
- in culina = in the kitchen
This is different from in + accusative, which can show motion into a place.
Compare:
- in culina manere = to remain in the kitchen
- in culinam ire = to go into the kitchen
Here there is no movement; the dish is staying where it is, so ablative is used.
Does sed connect two completely separate sentences, or two parts of what pater putat?
It connects two contrasting parts that both still depend on putat.
Structure:
- Pater putat
- canistrum a serva ad triclinium portatum esse
- sed catinum adhuc in culina manere
So the idea is:
- Father thinks [that the basket has been carried to the dining room], but [that the dish is still in the kitchen].
The second infinitive clause does not need another putat, because it is understood from the first part.
Does serva definitely mean a female slave here?
Yes. Serva is the feminine form.
- servus = male slave
- serva = female slave
So a serva specifically means by a female slave or by the slave-girl.
Sign up free — start using our AI language tutor
Start learning LatinMaster Latin — from Pater putat canistrum a serva ad triclinium portatum esse, sed catinum adhuc in culina manere to fluency
All course content and exercises are completely free — no paywalls, no trial periods, no signup needed.
- ✓Infinitely deep — unlimited vocabulary and grammar
- ✓Fast-paced — build complex sentences from the start
- ✓Unforgettable — efficient spaced repetition system
- ✓ AI tutor to answer your grammar questions